“Is he sick?”
“In a way,” I say, and instantly I hate how short I’m being with her. The way she’s looking at me, the concerned frown, and the way her eyes have gone soft with sympathy, tells me this isn’t callous curiosity. I sigh. “He’s… not well.”
Letting anything remotely like this out of my mouth is a bit of a new concept. I’ve carved out a very specific path for myself as the easy going, good time guy since Mom died when I was twenty. This type of thing is meant to stay buried in the box at the back of my closet. Not coming up in conversation with a woman I was trying to sleep with a couple days ago.
Is this what it’ll take to get her to like me? I’m not sure I can hack it.
“What’s in his lasagna?” Jenna asks abruptly, turning back to the freezer. “I’m sure if anyone can recreate it, it’s you. And I could help. I spent tons of time hiding out in my parents’ kitchen when I was younger. I picked up a few tricks from our chef.”
It’s completely transparent, but I’m grateful for the change of subject.
“You have a chef?”
She reaches into the freezer and pulls out two boxes of Bagel Bites, throwing them into the cart. “My parents have a chef. Their staff turned into my best friends growing up. I was a loner as a kid.”
“How is that possible?”
“There’s a weird girl at every school, isn’t there? No? Just ours? Well, you happen to be in the highly esteemed presence of Rotham Academy’s resident weirdo, class of 2012.”
“I can’t picture you as the resident weirdo.”
“Meanwhile, I can totally picture you as the lascivious cool kid who sat in the back of the class and refused to strip off his backwards hat, even when the teachers scolded you.” She appraises me. “Let’s see… You’re tall. Athletic. What were you, the star quarterback?”
“Star pitcher,” I correct with an eyebrow wiggle, and she groans. “And I would definitely have been the little shit in the back of the class, if they could ever get me to go to class.”
“Hooking up under the bleachers?”
“Nah, snuck them into the boys’ changing room.”
She laughs. “Ah, to be a man. I turned into the school pariah the very first time I had sex.”
“What?”
“Excuse me.”
Jenna tucks into my side, making room for a man trying to reach into the freezer. I should really just move to give her some space, but I can’t bring myself to. For a long time, I’ve suspected Jenna operates her own gravitational pull.
She hikes up the brim of my hat as she takes a step away from me. “Anyway, it was a small class, as I’m sure you can imagine at a private boarding school, so word really got around. Someone overheard the guy bragging about it and decided to tell just about everyone else. I was the first girl in my class to lose my virginity, or the first one to cop to it. And only the boys would give me the time of day after that.”
“Jenna, that’s…” Words start whizzing in my head. Fucked up. Devastating. But most of all: “That’s really unfair. I’m sorry that happened that you.”
She tips her head as if considering me. Sizing me up. Maybe deciding whether I’m worthy of her next few words. “It was my sister. The one who overheard. She ratted me out.”
The sputtering sound I make is somewhere between shock and disgust. “How does this story keep getting worse?”
She gives me a wry smile. “Not what you bargained for when you let me tag along, was it? I know it’s not really grocery-shopping-with-a-new-friend material.” She crosses her arms tight across her chest, and suddenly she looks more uncertain than I’ve ever seen her. Nothing like the woman I’m used to. “I’ve been told I can be a little intense. Over the top.”
I run a hand down my face. “Jenna, there are so many things wrong with what you just said, I don’t even know where to start. I like how intense you are. And that’s the wrong word anyway, because it makes it sound like a bad thing.” It’s there again. That skepticism as she looks at me. “Why does it feel like you just were just testing me?”
Her lips quirk. “Because I was.”
“And? Did I pass?”
Say yes.
Jenna gives me a long look before nodding at the freezer. “Do you want to try it? The lasagna?”
I slide open the glass door and grab a box. “Are you gonna answer the question?”