“She’d kick my ass.”
He nods his agreement. “And then she’d make you turn right around and undo it.”
I meet his eye at last, and there’s something so alive in them. Like he’s fondly picturing it, the way Mom would glower at me until I got it together. I feel it all over again: the guilt at how badly I let Dad down over the years. About how I’d hidden from the loss of Mom at his expense.
“I never did sneak out again, by the way,” I tell him. “After the night I busted my nose.”
I don’t remember the last time his face lit up like this. “Your Mom was a genius.” Somehow, my face remembers how to smile. It’s not big. But it’s there. “You want to know her secret? She let me in on it, once.”
I resent the optimism that perks up in my chest. Like Dad’s about to offer me a silver bullet. The one that’ll get me to stop being like this. To let go of what happened with Mom, and then with Dad, and just let myself savor the fact that, somehow, I got a woman like Jenna to love me.
“No parent wants to watch their kids get hurt, make mistakes, especially not when we could see some of the ones you and your sister were making from a mile away. But Mom believed in letting you win and lose. There was a lesson in there about feeling the lows, so that you’d know to appreciate the highs when you had them. So that you wouldn’t throw them away.”
I sigh deeply. “Subtle.”
“I’m not shooting for subtlety, Finley. Unless you think there’s better for you out there—”
“There isn’t,” I say, recoiling in disgust. What a ridiculous concept. I knew from the start that, for me, falling in love would be a one-time event. That if it wasn’t with Jenna, it wouldn’t be with anyone.
“I know I’m not one to talk. I was drowning when we lost Mom, and I didn’t try very hard to come up for air. Even now, it’s still a fight. But I’m willing to give it a try. Hayley set me up with her therapist. It may be a good idea for you to see her as well.”
There’s a terrible joke in there somewhere, about a man they’ve called Good Time Finn needing therapy. Other than Dad and Hayley, there are only a handful of people in this world who have seen me any other way. I’m thinking about walking away from one of them. And I’ll probably lose two more when I do.
Therapy, huh?
“Don’t do it, Finley,” Dad says. “Turn around. Go back inside.”
Chapter 27
Jenna
They bring me back into the hospital room in a wheelchair, just in time to catch the look Jude exchanges with Theo. I don’t need to ask what it’s about. But I sweep every angle and corner of the room anyway, checking the space under every bit of furniture. I start looking for my phone until I remember it got destroyed in the crash.
“Where is he?” I turn to Theo, heart beating painfully fast. “I asked you to look after him. He’s having a hard time with all this—where’d you let him wander off to alone?”
“He wanted to be alone.” Theo runs an uncomfortable hand through his hair. “We haven’t seen him since you left. I went to look for him, tried calling him, and…”
“Jenna, I’m so sorry,” Jude says quietly. “He didn’t look good. We think he left.”
I grip the arm of my wheelchair with my good hand, just so it’ll stop shaking. “Left to get some air, or left me?” Jude stares at me grimly.
Did you really think he’d change for you? Imaginary Ronnie’s words claw through my insides. He left you in a hospital. You were never special enough to keep him. You see that now, don’t you?
Honestly? I don’t. What I see is that last look he gave me right before he saw the other car heading for us.
Finn was going to tell me yes. To stay with him, to move in for real. I was sure of it. I heard it in his voice when he called my name. I saw the way he looked at me like he was coming out of an epiphany.
I’ve spent the entire summer believing there was more to him than the way people saw him. All the wide smiles, the deflections, the women, the scorecard. He spent the entire summer proving me right. He spent the entire summer convincing me that I was special, showing me what I deserve out of the people who are supposed to love me.
I know him. He’s worried and scared. He’s traumatized, after what he’s been through. But Finn’s never let me down. I don’t believe he’d start today.
“Look again,” I tell Theo. “Find him. Make sure he’s okay.”
The man leaves the room so fast you’d think it was on fire.
Jude comes to crouch in front of my chair. “It’ll be alright, Jenna. No matter what happens. You could always stay with us—”
“He told me he loves me.”