“I know…but I think about it all the time. I can’t pretend we didn’t kiss, West. And I also can’t pretend that after we kissed, I didn’t want you to invite me back to your room and be in your bed, and—.”
“Ruby!” I choked out, having to mentally shove the mention of spending the night together in my bed out of my mind. I couldn’t go there. This conversation was traveling downhill in a runaway train car and I had zero clue how to stop it.
“That’s not why I’m bringing it up.” She squeezed her eyes shut before lifting both her hands to them and pressing down. “I’ve been replaying every single detail in my head over and over again these past few months. I thought it would fade, or that I’d get over it, but I haven’t. Every detail is still clear as day, and every time we hang out all I can think about is kissing you again.”
I stepped away now, running my hands through my hair, fully freaking out.
“Where is this coming from?” I asked instead of admitting the truth: that I played that memory in my mind like a movie too, remembering every detail. Her sucking on my bottom lip, and the little sound that had escaped her when I tugged her closer to me on the couch. Everything was still as clear as if it happened last night.
“Are you serious? You really haven’t thought about it?”
I ignored her question and raised a hand, forcing myself to stay as cool as I could manage. “Okay, talking. You’re right.” I started pacing, but only two steps at a time, not willing to get too far from her. “You want to talk. That’s fair. We should hash this out. I’m sorry I ever kissed you. This is all on me.”
Her lips parted in surprise and she shook her head. “That’s not what I meant. I’m not asking you to take accountability. We were both there. I wanted to kiss you. Still do, if I’m being honest.”
I groaned. “Don’t say that.”
“Why?”
“Because we can’t!”
She stared through narrowed eyes, folding her arms across her chest. To think, my major in college was communications. Guess that had no transferable skills in the real world.
“Why not?” she asked again calmly. “West…didn’t you…did you not…enjoy it?” Her voice was small now, even less confident than when she’d started this conversation.
“No. What? Fuck me.” I dragged my hand over my face, letting it linger by my eyes so I had an excuse not to look at Ruby and her crestfallen expression.
I sighed, trying to regain composure. “This isn’t about if I enjoyed it or not. You’re obviously beautiful.” Even though I meant it as a compliment, the delivery had Ruby cringing away from me.
“I just mean, you’re so important to me. You’re like family.”
I’d been a lonely kid, I’d been in denial about that, but as an adult I could admit it. Now my parents were a world away. Mrs. Mitchell checked in with me more in a day than my own mother did in a month. Those kinds of things left a small mark; they were bound to. No matter how much I filled up my life with successful career moments, friends, and women, none of those things could replace that deep-seated need to feel like a part of something. And nothing made me feel like a part of something more than the Mitchells.
Nothing could change. The risk was too high.
“Family,” she repeated and I nodded, eager for her to understand.
Her shoulders slouched forward. “Is that really how you see me?”
I nodded furiously. I needed to make her understand. “Yes.”
“Then why did you kiss me?”
“Lapse of judgement.”
She snapped back like that stung, and I wished I could press undo. The last thing I wanted was to hurt Ruby. That was why I didn’t want to talk about this in the first place. But I had to make her see that the two of us could never happen.
“Look, I need to be brave and spit it out. I have feelings for you, West. I have for a long time,” she said.
All the air was sucked right out of my lungs. The world went quiet then, except for the ringing in my ears.
Ruby’s declaration…
Those words…
They were the words I had been dancing around and expertly avoiding for years. I wasn’t a complete moron. I saw the way Ruby had always looked at me. I’d known her feelings existed somewhere deep down, or even occasionally right on the surface of our friendship. But I thought if they remained unspoken, they wouldn’t be real. I could continue to pretend they didn’t exist.
“Don’t say that,” I whispered. A terrible thing to say, in hindsight.