The words slip out before I can weigh whether or not this level of honesty is too much. With Tank, I’m less self-conscious and unabashedly honest in a way I never was in relationships. Not even with David—at least, to start.
I’ve been staring at Evie’s perfect, round cheeks but now look at Tank, expecting him to be watching the baby too. But he’s grinning at me in a way that assures me that my honesty wasn’t too much. Scooting closer, Tank wraps an arm around my back until I’m propped up by the pillow behind me but I can also lean into him.
“This is exactly where I want to be too,” he says, and my heart does a happy little skip in my chest.
Evie squeals, and we both shift to look back at her. She’s grinning at Tank, the same wide smile I saw during her bath.
“I was worried she didn’t like me when she wouldn’t stop crying,” Tank confesses, holding out his finger, which Evie grabs in her little fist.
“I don’t think you need to worry about that,” I say. “I bet she just had to poop—sometimes they get fussy and gassy right before. And then she did poop, so I’m sure she was crying because no one wants poop in their hair.”
Tank shudders. “I definitely don’t. I didn’t even like it on my clothes. And hands. Ugh. No more poop talk.”
“Fair enough. At least, until she does it again.” I laugh at his expression. “I doubt she’ll have another blowout so soon. We’re probably safe. Anyway, I really am glad you called me. I’m happy to help. This is the highlight of my week, actually.”
Tank pulls back a little to give me a pointed look. “Really? The baby is the highlight of your week? Not anything else?”
“Should I have another highlight, Theo?”
He leans closer, his lips brushing my ear as he murmurs, “I love being with my granddaughter, but I have another highlight in mind. Need me to tell you about it? Or, maybe I could show you. See if it changes your vote to something else.”
His words travel like a current over my skin, and I have to pull back a little to keep my head clear.
“I think showing me would be a bad idea right now, all things considered. You might distract me from my very important baby-holding duties.”
Tank chuckles, but gives me a look promising he’ll show me later. “Fair enough.”
“Why don’t you tell me about Jo?”
While letting Evie grip his finger in her tiny hand, Tank tells me the full story of how Pat and Lindy met, dated, broke up, then met again in Sheet Cake.
“Let me get this straight—you accidentally bought the town where your son’s ex grew up?” I ask.
“I did. And he ran into her the very first time we came here, right after I told him about the wildly impulsive thing I did.”
“Wow. That is wild.”
He goes on to explain about the custody battle Lindy was having with her sister over Jo. “I suspect their expedited marriage was something more of an arrangement at the start, though neither of them has ever admitted it to me. Even if it was, very quickly, it became more than that.”
I ask about James, Collin, and Harper, and as Tank talks about his children finding their significant others, Evie falls asleep in my arms, still gripping Tank’s finger. We talked about our children the night of our date, but he goes deeper now, sharing some of the fears and worries he’s had over Pat’s impulsiveness, James’s stubbornness, and Collin’s struggle with his business and finding his identity.
“I worried more for Harper earlier and less for her now that she figured out she was in love with Chase,” he says with a chuckle. “I can’t wait for her to meet you.”
Though things have been great with Tank’s sons and their significant others, I worry slightly about Harper. Not for any good reason. Maybe just because I would hate for her not to like me.
Tank asks about John and Chelsea, and I confess that I think John is too serious and works too much. I don’t say I think he’s too much like his father in some ways.
“Chelsea and Mason are doing great together, and my only issue is trying not to pressure them about when they’re going to give me a grandbaby,” I say. “Evie can maybe help tide me over for a little bit.”
“She’s amazing,” Tank says. “I wasn’t sure how I would feel—like if it would be similar or different from Jo. I was a little nervous, to be honest. I just didn’t want to … love her more somehow. Or have Jo feel like I did.”
I’ve seen Tank with Jo a time or two from a distance. When I was leaving the wedding after dropping off the cake, I remember hearing Jo squeal and seeing Tank swing her around on the dance floor. Even then, I remember the way it made my chest burn. Though it’s nothing compared to how I feel in this moment, with one of Tank’s arms wrapped around my back and Evie’s tiny fist curled around his finger.
This ordinary moment feels like more.
It feels, I realize, a little bit like forever.
“I have no doubt Jo knows how much you love her. Your heart seems to have the capacity to love deep and love wide,” I tell him. “And what’s more, you make no attempts to hide it. You carry that love around with you and wave it like a banner so everyone can see.”