The unspoken accusation fell between them.
“Do you want to know what truly happened all those years ago, or do you want to keep believing the lies your father told you?” she asked at last.
The bitterness in her voice startled him almost as much as her words.
“I know what happened,” he informed her curtly. “You abandoned your son and husband in favor of your lover.”
The pain of her choice remained deep and agonizing. The same lad who had gleefully absconded with the tree baubles had been the one she had sent away. The lad who had cried in the dark for his mother whilst she had been warming her bed with her baseborn paramour. As a child, he hadn’t understood it. That had dawned eventually, when he’d been of an age.
“I never abandoned you,” the duchess denied. “Your father took you from me.”
“Perhaps,” Arch countered, “but only because you had forced his hand with your actions.”
“It was wrong of me to do what I did.”
His mother’s concession shocked him, compelling his gaze up from the chessboard’s disarray. “You are many years too late in that acknowledgment.”
“I was in love with Charles,” she said softly. “But the love I felt for him paled compared to the love I held in my heart for you. It did then, and it does now. You are my son, a piece of me. I carried you in my womb and gave you life.”
Arch’s molars were on edge. He didn’t want to think about the bastard who had upended his life. Didn’t want to think of his name.
“I should think I have considerably less competition now that he’s dead,” he said coldly.
His mother flinched, and he knew a sharp slice of regret at causing her pain. But then he forced it down, allowing it to melt away like the snow on his boots. Charles Trask had been the head gardener at Winterbury Abbey. And despite his clandestine affair with the duchess, had remained so until his death, a mere four months before Arch’s own father had died in his sleep.
“There was never competition between you,” the duchess said. “I loved you both, differently and in my own way. I love you still, Archibald.”
“Pity you didn’t love me enough to cast your lover aside and be my mother when I had need of you,” he bit out.
“Do you truly believe that I cast you away?” Her chin trembled, her eyes glistening with unshed tears. “That I chose Charles over you? Because I can assure you that I did nothing of the sort. You were older than the age of seven, and by law, your father could take you from me. I petitioned for access to you, but I was denied. He was a powerful man, and I had made the grave error of falling in love with someone who was not my husband. I was an adulterer and he was a duke, even if he had committed the same sins as I had.”
Arch searched for any hint of subterfuge and found only candor in her expression, her gaze unwavering. “Father was faithful to you.”
His mother inclined her head. “No doubt he told you so.”
Yes, his father had. But in his later years, he had kept mistresses. Many of them. Arch had simply ignored his father’s private whims, knowing he was likely lonely. That he wasn’t to blame for having a wife who had been perfidious and selfish, who had chosen a gardener over her husband and son. It had seemed only fair that his father had sought comfort and companionship in the arms of others.
“He perhaps had…liaisons,” he acknowledged with great difficulty, “but these were later, many years after you had already cuckolded him with Trask.”
“Your father kept a woman almost everywhere he traveled,” the duchess said. “On our wedding night, he left me and went to an actress he kept in a grand house. She bore him a child, but the boy died not long after he was born.”
Shock robbed him of breath. He’d had a half sibling? But…how? Surely he would have known.
He shook his head. “I am thirty years old. Why would you only tell me this now, unless it somehow benefits you to do so, when my father is no longer alive to defend the reputation you seek to tarnish?”
“When was I to have told you the truth?” she asked softly. “You have never wanted to hear it. I have tried on many occasions after you were old enough to comprehend.”
Had she?
Arch raked the coals of his memories for proof that she had. Visits with her had been stilted, presided over by his father for many years. Then later, as a man grown, he hadn’t wanted to listen to her, it was true. His loyalty had belonged to the duke. His calls had been sparse, his replies to her letters and entreaties to visit almost nonexistent.
“Her name was Jenny Ballon then,” his mother continued. “The actress who bore your father a son. There were other babies as well in those early days, from various different women, but I don’t know of any children who survived. You perhaps have half siblings who are equally unaware of your existence. I would have liked to believe he would have made a provision for them in his will, but…”
He stared. She was not lying. These were facts too precise to be invented, and the open, earnest expression on his mother’s face told him she was being utterly honest.
His world seemed to be falling apart at the seams. He couldn’t look at his mother. His eyes fell to the chessboard, which seemed to be mocking him. All at once, he picked up the neatly carved wooden king and hurled it into the fireplace. It landed with a crack and quickly caught flame.
“That chessboard belonged to your father,” his mother said.