The duchess settled her teacup in its saucer with a clatter. “Will you never forgive me, my son?”
He suddenly couldn’t bear to finish the tea or to face her any longer. She had not called him son in years, though she often did so in her letters, and it settled on his heart like the crushing weight of a boulder.
“There are some sins which cannot be absolved, madam,” he said hoarsely, returning his tea to the tray.
Rising to his feet, Arch offered her as elegant a bow as he could muster before he left his mother alone in the drawing room, surrounded by the festive Christmas displays Miss Shawcross had arranged for her.
It was best that he departed in the morning.
At the last minute before the dinner gong sounded, the duchess had refused to take dinner in the dining room.
“I am feeling positively bilious,” she had informed Jane.
No amount of coaxing on Jane’s part had persuaded Her Grace to alter her position on the matter. Jane had taken note of the redness in the duchess’s eyes, along with the puffy bags beneath them. She firmly believed, although she would never utter a word of her suspicions aloud, that the proud and august woman had been weeping this afternoon.
She was certain she also knew the cause.
He was seated across from her at dinner, dressed in an elegant coat of jet black that rendered his eyes even more beautiful. His hair was swept from his high forehead, and he somehow managed to look bored and aloof at once. His necktie and shirt were crisp, startling white, his waistcoat a sleek dove gray. Everything about him, from the signet ring on his finger, to the exacting tailoring of his evening finery, emanated ducal perfection. The lone disparity was in the dark shadow of whiskers on the Duke of Winterbury’s rigid jaw, which she suspected was not from a lack of proper shaving from his valet’s capable hand. Rather, it was as if his potent masculinity could not be contained by a mere razor.
There was no denying the infuriating man’s sensual allure, even if Jane longed to dump the vase of flowers between them into his lap. Dinner was proving excruciating thus far, and they were only on the soup course. He had been polite, of course. But colder than the night air.
“You are frowning into your potage à la faubonne,” the duke commented. “Dare I fear you are about to start berating your vegetables?”
He was referring to her habit of talking to herself. It was not lost on her that he had heard her doing so on two occasions now. But it was rather unkind of him to remind her of it.
“I only speak to my soup when I’m alone, Your Grace,” she returned, forcing a polite smile to her lips.
He paused with his spoon in his bowl to regard her with his distinctive gaze. “Ah, then I am doomed to disappointment. I must admit I was rather looking forward to witnessing the proper method of haranguing a julienned carrot.”
It was unsettling, being the sole recipient of this man’s attention. Weathering his solemn intensity felt as inadvisable as trying to breathe underwater—both were inherently dangerous. How she wished the duchess had not cried off joining them at the last moment. Jane might have done so as well, but Her Grace had insisted she join the duke, leaving her refusal all but impossible.
He awaited Jane’s answer now as if they were engaged in a deeply intellectual conversation, as if everything hinged upon her response. Better, she supposed, to speak of nonsensical things than of the glaring absence of his mother, which Jane did not doubt he had caused.
She inclined her head with what she hoped was a regal air. “I would never so mistreat a poor, innocent root vegetable, Your Grace.”
“Your condemnation is reserved for others, then,” he observed smoothly, dipping his spoon into his soup.
“My condemnation is reserved for where it belongs.” She sipped at her soup before she could say more.
Indeed, what she had said was already foolish enough.
“Or perhaps for where you perceive it to belong,” he countered. “Not everything is always as it seems, Miss Shawcross, nor is everyone who you think them to be.”
Was he trying to suggest he wasn’t worthy of her condemnation? When he had all but exiled his own mother to Northumberland and couldn’t be bothered to return her letters, ignoring her pleas that he visit her at Christmastime for years? That was rich. But then, he was a duke. Likely, he believed himself above reproach at all times.
“I must admit that I am shocked you are concerned with my opinion of others, Your Grace,” she said mildly, resuming eating her soup.
Pity she could scarcely taste it, let alone enjoy it, given his observation of her, which seemed to steal all the air from the room.
He quirked a brow. “Concerned is perhaps too strong a word, madam. I do believe that curious is more apt.”
“I find it equally perplexing to be the object of your curiosity.” She abandoned her soup in favor of the wine she had yet to touch, thinking perhaps it would calm her unsettled nerves. “I can assure you that nothing about me is interesting in the slightest.”
There was something disconcerting about the way his gaze had dipped to her lips. Heat flared low in her belly, spreading outward like a cup of tea that had been unceremoniously spilled and, once upended, could no longer be returned or confined.
The whole of his attention was upon her suddenly, all pretense of eating his soup abandoned, his spoon settled in his bowl. Whilst she had thought his stare was disquieting before, now she felt as if the full, blazing force of the sun had been fixed upon her. She was warm all over. And although she knew it unwise, she couldn’t seem to look away.
“I do believe you seek to mislead me, Miss Shawcross,” he said softly, his tone of voice deepening ever so slightly and becoming almost intimate, as if the two of them shared a secret. “I find you quite interesting. It isn’t every day, after all, that one becomes acquainted with someone so adept at holding a conversation with oneself. Or someone who seems to have such an original relationship with gravity.”