On one hand, I felt completely like myself around Neptune. On the other, I was nervous and speechless when he was near. I didn’t know if that was because I needed to get used to him again or because I needed to tell him my truth. Either way, a part of me was happy to see him again, and the other wanted to run back to Washington.
As soon as I entered, the smell of coffee beans instantly calmed me. Rather than immediately ordering myself a latte, I headed through the cream and green lobby and looked around until my eyes landed on Neptune. As if he felt someone heading in his direction, his eyes shifted from the window to me, and I smiled. All my nausea dissolved when he smiled and stood. I didn’t know why I expected him to hug me, but when he didn’t, I was a little disappointed. Still, he pulled my chair back as he said, “Morning, bae.”
“Morning. How are you?”
“I’m good. How are you?” he replied as I sat down.
“Nervous.”
Neptune laughed as he took his seat across from me. The white tee and light wash jeans gave him a casual look that did nothing to diminish his attractiveness.
“Why are you nervous, Lani?”
“Shame,” I admitted easier than I thought I would. His expression softened, and I continued. “I’m sorry, Neptune. What happened between us, that was all my fault. I was operating from a heightened amount of frazzled, unregulated emotions. You were absolutely right about us not being ready for marriage, and I had such a fixed mindset that I was incapable of seeing that truth.
“Add to that feeling rejected by the boy I loved, and that was a huge hit to my ego. I can admit I stayed away those first couple of years because I hated and resented you, but the more I healed, the more I stayed away because of my shame and guilt over how I acted. So before we do anything else, I just wanted to say I’m sorry. Can you forgive me?”
His eyes misted over, and he licked the corner of his mouth as his head tilted. Clearing his throat, Neptune looked away from me briefly before almost whispering, “You have nothing to apologize for, Milani.”
“Yes, I do. I know the way I acted hurt you, and I know you broke up with me because you felt like you had no other choice. You had to because I practically forced you to. Otherwise, I was going to ruin our futures. I can’t imagine how hard that was for you, but Franko gave me insight here and there. Can you forgive me?”
“Of course I can forgive you. I love you.”
Hearing him say that was like a weight off my shoulders as I smiled and wiped away a tear before it could fall. My breath came out shaky before I muttered, “Whew,” then giggled. I knew I’d still have to tell him about the baby, though that was the kind of secret I considered taking to my grave. What reason did I have to tell him a truth that would hurt? It wasn’t like we were getting back together. If we did, he’d definitely need to know.
“I love you too,” I declared, and doing so felt different from the way it felt when I told Ethan I loved him. Not wanting to compare them, I twiddled Ethan’s ring around my finger. I’d put it on to remind myself that, even though I hadn’t said yes to the marriage, there was a man waiting for me. That meant I couldn’t entangle myself with Neptune.
Our eyes remained locked until the intensity caused me to look away. Not wasting any time, Neptune said, “Don’t shut down on me now.”
“We’re not here for me to be putting us in our feelings. We’re supposed to be planning Risen’s welcome home party.”
“We don’t have to,” Neptune said, causing my eyes to find his again.
“What do you mean?”
“I’m paying my sister to do it. It’ll be scheduled for six months out. She’s going to take care of everything. All we’ll have to do is approve.”
Through my laugh, I asked, “I don’t know why it didn’t cross my mind that you’d do that. So what are we here for?”
“I had the idea to do a lil family dinner for Franko and Rissa this weekend. Just us, y’all parents, and Rissa’s parents. That’ll give them time to get settled and feel loved on until the party for Risen.”
“Aww, that’s actually really sweet, Neptune. I’m sure they’ll love that.”
“Plus, I wanted to talk to you. I think we needed to have a conversation, and clearly, you were on the same page. Shit can’t be weird between us the whole time you’re here, Milani.”
“You’re right. That’s why I had to get that off my chest.”
“I need to get some shit off my chest too, but did you want to get something to eat or drink first?”
“Oh, God. Not if you’re going to yell at me or read me for filth.”
A hearty laugh escaped him that made me smile, even though I was serious.
I missed the sight of him happy and laughing so much.
“Nah, none of that. I actually wanted to apologize too. Do a little catching up.”
“You have absolutely nothing to apologize for,” was what I said, but he quickly waved me off.