He rolls his eyes. “Oh no. A Christmas fan. Let me guess, you make themed cookies every week to go along with the movie?”
“And I make cookie boxes to give out,” I add. It’s my little act of Christmas good for the year.
“And you have themes pajamas?” He bites his lower lip. “Maybe with Santa hats?”
“They’re festive,” I defend.
“Uh-huh. And you have a standing order at local florist shop. Poinsettias delivered as soon as they’re ready.”
“I’m supporting local businesses!”
“Ah, so you are Mrs. Claus.” He leans close, and I inhale. Whiskey, ginger, and the slightest hint of motor oil wrap around me. It fits—and it’s my new favorite scent. “My lucky night.”
My cheeks brighten, and I shift, patting my face. Holy fuck, what is happening? “I just really like this time of the year.”
The lights. The cozy vibes. The only time my mother seems to genuinely like me—I sink into that feeling and bask in it for as long as it’ll last.
“I’m sure. I have to ask,” he drawls, staring at my lips and my body hums. “If you’re not making videos, then why the outfit?”
Shifting, I try to pull the skirt down. It does no good. His eyes fasten on my warm skin, a strange flicker of desire igniting from his gaze.
“Would you believe me if I told you it was to see my boyfriend?”
His shoulders slump immediately. He’s as sad as a kicked dog. “Oh, really? You have a boyfriend.”
“Did,” I correct. “This was to surprise him. Only I was the one who got a surprise.” He sits, silently, watching me. I think he’s the first to do so. “He was fucking another woman,” I say, shrugging. Grinch’s jaw clenches. “So, we’re not together anymore. He said, and I quote, ‘Why would I stay with you, when you’re such a boring lay?’ End quote. That was fun.”
Granted, it was said with a gun at his temple. He then pleaded for his life, but still. It was the truth.
Hurt pangs in my hollow chest. I’ve had worse thrown at me—enemies, innocents I’ve had to kill for my family. But Andy’s words strike something deeper. An insecurity that I’ve masked my entire life. I’m defective. And he threw it into my face.
Gripping my chin, Grinch hauls me close, noses brushing. His touch is ownership, dominance; as if I’ve always belonged to him. I melt into it.
If past boyfriends had touched me like this, maybe I would’ve enjoyed sex more.
“He’s a fucking idiot,” he seethes quietly. “Forget the outfit, because any normal man would drop to their knees and thank God for this, but for you too. Just you.” He bites his lips, snorting. “You have to realize how fucking sexy you are. If he couldn’t see it, then it’s his loss.”
I swallow hard, searching his eyes for the joke. I’m almost thirty, and I can’t remember the last time someone called me sexy. I just don’t get that.
Yet this total stranger says it as if it’s hard gospel.
Blinking, I pout slightly. His eyes don’t leave my mouth. What I want to say, do, might not be appreciated. It might be completely ignored. But I’m compelled to voice what I want. What I need. To do so with a stranger seems safe.
“What would you do if you got this gift?”
“Probably cry. Maybe send a prayer to Santa. Most definitely fucking appreciate it.”
His hand is hot against my chin, and I bite my lip. He smirks.
“Ask what you really want, Claus.” The words cause me to shudder.
This is a bad idea. My mother would hate it. But damn, I want it.
“I have a car. We could…” I trail off.
If he denies me, so be it. But I hope he doesn’t ruin my confidence like freshly fallen snow.
He exhales harshly. “Merry fucking Christmas to me.”