The truth hit him like a bolt of lightning. Alice had stolen his heart in a matter of days, and he might never get a chance to tell her. Might not even get a chance to try and build a future together. Knots tied his insides into a hundred different loops, each one tightening with every bump in the road, every thought, every breath.
Lane sped across the country road. Stars filled the moonless sky. A house sat away from the quiet street tucked into a smattering of trees. “This is the house.”
Spencer’s back went rigid. He stared out the window, relief threading through the cracks of anxiousness in his chest. A car sat in the driveway and lights blazed from multiple windows. “She’s home.”
“We don’t all need to go up there,” Duke said. “It might scare her if she looks outside and sees three men on the porch that she doesn’t know.
“I’ll go.” Spencer was out of the truck before Lane had it in park. He jogged to the front door and rang the bell. He fought against the urge to peek in the window to see if anyone was coming.
Finally, the door opened a crack. “Hello?”
He couldn’t see the woman who was on the other side of the door, but he talked anyway. “I’m sorry to bother you, but my name is Spencer. I’m looking for Sara. I have some questions for her about Neil Vito.”
A derisive snort reached his ears, and the door opened a fraction further. “Why do you want to know anything about that asshole?”
He debated how to answer. He didn’t want to scare this woman but also needed her to understand how dire it was he speak with her. “Because I think he kidnapped my girlfriend.”
A sharp gasp told him that he’d made the right choice.
“I knew it. I told her to stay away from him. That he was trouble.” The door opened to reveal a tall curvy woman in her mid-twenties. Her light hair was in a messy bun, and she wore pink and white striped pajamas.
Her words penetrated the thick fog holding him hostage. “You aren’t Sara.”
“I’m Jane, her roommate.” She wrapped her arms around her middle. “Do you really think Neil took your girlfriend?”
“I don’t think, I know. That’s why I need to talk to Sara. The sheriff’s department is searching for him but keeps coming up empty. I hoped Sara could tell us where he might be. It’s important that I speak to her and quickly. I need to find him before he hurts Alice.”
Jane frowned, her eyes wide and full of worry. “I’m sorry but Sara isn’t here. I haven’t been able to reach her since yesterday.”
He took a step back to absorb the physical blow that came with the confession.
“Do…do you think he could have Sara, too?”
He mentally flipped through the possibilities. There were too my variables, too many unknowns.
Too many unanswered questions he had no way of figuring out.
“Has he ever physically assaulted Sara before?” he asked.
“Not that she told me, but she kept a lot to herself. We’ve been friends since we were young. She’s always been shy and private, not liking to complain. But I noticed a few bruises. Saw her wither away in the time they were together.”
“How long was that?”
“Long enough to think she was in love. They’d discussed marriage. I tried to open her eyes and talk her out of it.”
“She must have listened,” he said.
Another snort. “No. They started building a house together. She said he wanted to put in the work and make her proud. Nothing turned the tides until she started reading those newspaper articles. She said the woman who wrote them really spoke to her, like she was telling her each week how to make her life better.”
“Oh, God. That’s why he went after Alice.” It all made sense. Targeting the newspaper office, sending the threatening email, breaking into her house to torment her. He wanted revenge for the end of his relationship. “You said you haven’t heard from Sara. Is that normal? Is there anywhere she would have gone to have alone time or even to hide if she felt threatened?”
“I…I don’t know. I don’t think so.”
“What about this house they were building?” he asked, adrenaline zipping through his veins. “What happened with it when they broke up?”
Jane shook her head. “She never said.”
“Do you know where it is?”