The side of his mouth inched up. “Pretty high.”
“Then why do you want to pass me off to someone else?” God, she sounded pathetic.
The waitress returned and slid cups of water in front of them before gifting them each with a large helping of ice cream drizzled with thick fudge and topped with a mound of whipped cream. “Need anything else?”
She beamed up at the older woman. “No thank you. This is perfect.”
The server returned her smile then retreated into the kitchen.
She slid a spoonful of cold, sweet ice cream into her mouth and stifled a groan then pointed her spoon at Spencer. “I’m waiting for an answer.”
Sighing, Spencer dug into his own sundae. A dot of fudge stained his chin. “I’m not trying to get rid of you.”
“It feels like it. I don’t know Lane that well, and I’ve only met Duke a couple times. I don’t trust them like I trust you.” If she were honest with herself, she wasn’t sure why she trusted Spencer as much as she did. She didn’t know him that well, but there was something about him. Something about the way he made her feel that she didn’t want to give up.
“Maybe you shouldn’t,” he mumbled, dropping his gaze along with his utensil. He crossed his arms over his chest and leaned back.
Interesting. He was blocking her not only with his words, but his actions. With his body language. This was a side of him she hadn’t seen, and instead of scaring her and making her want to run, she wanted to crack him open and find out what made him tick.
“What could you have done differently today?” She set her own spoon on the table, giving him her whole attention.
Snorting out a humorless laugh, he shook his head as though he couldn’t believe she’d ask such a question. “I shouldn’t have taken you on a joy ride through the damn woods for starters.”
“And left me alone? What would have happened if the person you were after looped back around and found me?”
He wrinkled his nose. “Okay, so that would have been a dumb decision. We both should have stayed behind.”
“And not tried to chase down the person tormenting me? That’s not what I wanted. I told you to take me with you. I asked to let me ride along. That was my choice, not yours. You can’t blame yourself for an accident, and I do want to stress the word accident, when I’m the one who jumped on the back of that ATV. You didn’t have a gun to my head.”
“But you didn’t know my leg still gives me trouble,” he shot back. “You didn’t know my muscles could lock up, which could lead to that accident. What if that happens again? If we’re in a situation when you’re depending on me to keep you alive and my body won’t to do what it’s supposed to do—then things fall apart. They go to shit, and I can’t control it, and something even worse happens to you.”
The crack in his voice twisted her heart, and she couldn’t resist sliding her arm across the table and flipping up her palm. She wiggled her fingers, a silent invitation for him to take her hand.
He pressed his lips together as if trying to suppress a smile.
His hand was warm in hers, sending tingles of excitement shooting to her core. She couldn’t dwell on the avalanche of feelings he stirred in her right now. She’d do that later while lying awake in bed. Right now she had to focus on getting him to hear what she had to say.
“I’m sorry that you’ve had this challenge placed in your life. I’m even sorrier that it’s made you doubt yourself. But you and I both know that life hands each of us all sorts of obstacles. Most of them unfair and a pain in the ass. We have two choices. Let those obstacles trip us up over and over or learn how to navigate them so they no longer control us. No longer dictate the decisions we make. I’m not concerned about your ability to keep me safe. I believe in you. And I want you to believe in yourself.”
Swishing his lips to the side, he squeezed her hand. “You must be one hell of a shrink. What you say makes sense, but…”
“Yeah, yeah, yeah. Makes sense but doesn’t mean it’s easy. I get it. I really do. Just do me a favor and think about what I said. I’d hate to see you lose out on anything in life because you can’t get out of your own way.”
“I promise.”
Picking up her spoon, she slid another delicious bite in her mouth. She wouldn’t push, but she also wouldn’t agree to speaking to one of the other men from Rough Ride Security. She’d hope a good night’s sleep would help put his head on straight, and that no trouble found her in the meantime.
11
Spencer slammed the refrigerator door closed and leaned against his kitchen counter. No food here held an ounce of appeal. Hours had passed since his conversation with Alice and dropping her off at home, but the words she said played on repeat in his head.
Yes, she’d made some good points. And yes, logic told him he should follow her advice. But there was more to it than deciding to not let his issues mess with his head. Honestly, how was he supposed to do that when the issue caused physical limitations that kept him from doing his job?
Rethinking the contents of his fridge, he reached inside and pulled out a cold bottle of beer. A knock at the door stopped him from screwing off the top. He scowled and stormed to the front door to reveal who’d shown up to intrude on his broody solitude.
Duke grinned and hoisted a six pack of his favorite brew in the air. His gaze landed on the bottle in Spencer’s hand and one brow quirked up, disappearing under his cowboy hat. “Looks like we had the same idea.”
“I like yours better because you paid. I’ll put mine back.”