“Eventually, I decided there was nothing left for me here, so I left.” Hael’s thumb moved across the back of his hand, a tiny gesture of comfort. Keir looked down at their joined fingers before continuing. “The first person I met outside the kingdom was a witch.” He stopped there, his expression changing, then he drew in a breath.
Hael took over after noticing the shift. “Her name was Shoodar. She was an earth witch.”
“The sleeping witch?” I gasped in shock.
I knew her tale, or the tale I heard from my mother. It was the story Ophelia told me at the tree. She was the last witch that went off on the revenge spree… Keir knew her? How old was he?
“The very same, Moon Bird. She did have a strange name.” Hael nodded solemnly. “She could command the elements, though earth was her strongest gift. She understood herbs, roots, flowers, things that grew beneath the soil and things that could be coaxed from it. She helped Haden when he was weak.”
My gaze landed on Keir at the old name, but he didn’t seem to mind Hael using it now.
“But… when the Salem witch trials began,” Hael continued, “something inside her changed.”
The warmth disappeared from his expression. “The times women were being accused, and witches were being hunted?” I asked, recalling Ophelia’s story.
“Yes,” Hael replied, placing a kiss on my shoulder before he continued. “Some were killed, some disappeared, and Shoodar… She was consumed by revenge. She began killing humans in their sleep. She would enter their homes without a sound and drain them of their blood.” Hael’s voice remained quiet, almost clinical. “Twenty people could die in a single month, sometimes more.”
“And nobody stopped her?” I asked, a chill running through my body at the thought of her being free still.
“Dark magic rarely stops at the boundary you give it,” Keir added. “It keeps asking for more, and Shoodar… she kept giving it more.”
Keir’s gaze lowered to the table. “She wanted more deaths, but there was a problem.” He paused, cupped my face in his palms and smiled, grounding me and reminding me that it was okay, that they were here and my fears were for things of the past. “Shoodar was powerful, but she was still human. She couldn’t keep feeding the darkness indefinitely. She needed something stronger than herself, something she could use as a vessel.”
He looked at Hael, then back at me. “So she turned to me.”
I shuddered and swallowed hard, goosebumps spreading across my skin.
“She found the loneliness that still resided in me, then channeled the madness.” His jaw tightened. “She took everything I’d endured during those two decades and twisted it. My isolation, my anger, my grief, my hatred, my guilt. She turned it into something so dark that eventually I couldn’t tell where her magic ended and my own mind began.”
Hael’s hand tightened around his again in a grounding gesture, but Keir continued without acknowledging it.
“I didn’t know much about dark magic then. I only knew that she had discovered exactly what I could become.” His golden eyes darkened. “She turned me into the perfect monster, her perfect killer.”
“Keir…” I reached out to his face, my palm resting on his cold skin. He welcomed my touch, shutting his eyes for a second and leaning into my hand. After a while, he held my hand to his face and kissed my inner wrist, his eyes opening again and meeting mine.
“I killed for her.” The words landed with such simplicity that I almost wished he had dressed them in something softer. “Humans, witches, vampires. I killed both the innocent and guilty. At the time it really stopped mattering.” His thumb moved absently over Hael’s knuckles. “At one point Shoodar stopped having to order me. I was very good at it and before long became the Hallow Massacre.”
“What?” I gasped, shock, fear, rage, and confusion coursing through my veins. The Hallow Massacre was the darkest time in all the history books. It was worse than any plague. I remember my mother telling me the stories. It was part of the many reasons the past intrigued me so much.
I stared at him, trying to reconcile the man sitting before me with the creature my imagination had once feared in the darkness. “How long?” I asked quietly.
Keir’s eyes lifted. “Long enough.”
There was no pride in his answer, no attempt to excuse himself. “I thought that was all I would ever be.” Then his gaze shifted toward Hael and something changed so completely that I felt it before he even spoke.
“Until I met him.” Keir smiled, small and almost disbelieving, and lifted Hael’s hand to his lips. “And then everything became complicated.”
Hael’s expression softened as he turned to me with a smile, his face barely inches away from mine. “I was born to a Catholic family and wanted to become a priest long before I understood what the world could do to a person.” He glanced toward Keir. “I was studying for the priesthood when the plague found me.”
“You were sick?” I asked, chest tightening as I pictured him deathly ill.
“Dying,” he corrected gently. “There was very little anyone could do.” His gaze lowered briefly, remembering something buried beneath centuries. “Then Keir came.”
“He was stubborn even while dying.” Keir smiled faintly.
“And you were insufferable even while rescuing me.” Hael chuckled lightly, before kissing my shoulder again. Did these men understand the concept of trying to focus? Because they were making it almost impossible for me.
“You survived,” Keir replied.