I sat at her funeral and watched my dad fold in on himself, watched my brothers fall apart, heard her favorite Christmas songs come on in the grocery store, and had to leave before anyone saw my face.
But I’ve never cried.
I couldn’t. My family fell apart around me, and someone needed to keep it together, so I did. And in the process, I avoided all the triggers that would break me down. Year after year, Christmas after Christmas, I stopped decorating, stopped baking, stopped visiting the clock shop she co-owned with her best friend, stopped listening to the songs she loved, stopped talking about her quite so much. It was easier. If I didn’t let myself remember, then I didn’t have to feel the hole she left behind. I thought I was okay, until River baked her favorite Christmas cookie, which my dad used to argue wasn’t a Christmas cookie at all, and now I’m reduced to a ten-year-old boy standing in my mom’s kitchen with flour on my hands while she hums Christmas songs.
I don’t realize I’m crying until it’s streaming down my face, dropping against the recipe card beneath me.
“Easton?” River’s voice comes from behind me, gentle, comforting. I can’t answer him, don’t even turn around. His footsteps are soft and sure, his arms wrapping around me. There are no questions, no panic, just warmth. “I’m sorry.” His voice is so quiet, so unsure. I can hear it, and my heart aches.
“Don’t be, baby.”
“I didn’t mean to . . .”
I turn in his arms, closing my eyes and letting him hold me while I fall apart for the first time in years. My forehead drops against his shoulder, his hands rubbing up and down my back in a comforting caress.
“Easton, if I did something, I’m so sor—”
“Please don’t apologize, you didn’t do anything wrong. I haven’t done this in a very long time,” I confess. River just continues to hold me, rubbing my back and hushing me.
“You’re okay, everything is okay,” he lulls, so damn sweet and sincere. I pull back just enough to look at him, his hands moving to my face to gently wipe my tear-stricken skin. His eyes are wet, like my sadness somehow affected him this deeply.
“You found this?” I ask, holding up the recipe card.
“Yeah, I was looking for paper and tape, found it in your junk drawer.” My throat tightens. I had my mom’s beloved recipe in the goddamn junk drawer. The tears fall harder. “Hey, talk to me,” River insists.
I shake my head. “She loved Christmas,” I blubber. River guides me to the couch, wrapping his arms around me.
“Talk to me.”
“My mom loved Christmas more than anyone I’ve ever known. She’d start decorating the day after Halloween, completely skipping Thanksgiving decorations, every single year, the whole damn house. She’d make cookies—gingerbread, sugar, thumbprint, but those,” I say, looking back at the kitchen, “those were her favorite. She’d sing Christmas songs, and hell, she was so bad at it.”
River snorts. “Bad at singing?”
“The worst, absolutely terrible. But she’d dance around the kitchen, and my dad would pretend it drove him nuts. We were all happy.”
“What happened?”
“She died.”
“Oh, Easton . . .”
“After that, Christmas just . . .” I let my words trail off. “Everywhere I looked, she was there. Every light reminded me of her, every Christmas song, cookie, every stupid ornament. So, I just stopped. I convinced myself that if I didn’t celebrate, maybe it would eventually stop the hurt.”
“Did it?”
I tear slides down my cheek. “No. It just meant that I missed her in the silence. I was just afraid that if I let myself remember how much she loved Christmas, I’d have to admit how much I missed her.”
River gently grabs my face, angling my head toward him. “You don’t have to stop loving Christmas because she died.”
“I don’t know how to love it without her here.”
“Maybe you don’t have to. Maybe you can love it because of her. She’s a part of you, East. She’s in everything you do, whether you realize it or not. You pretend you don’t care, but you care deeper than anyone I’ve ever met. Look at the way you took me in, no questions asked, the way you went along with every single one of my wild ideas.”
“That was to keep you from hurting yourself or others,” I quip, making him smile.
“You can tell yourself that, but I know it’s because you care. You let me bring a tree into your home, you wore the Christmas sweater and the matching pajama pants.” My chest aches. “You don’t have to put Christmas away just because missing her hurts.”
“She would have loved you, River.” That causes him to still. I don’t know why I said it, I don’t know what the future will bring us, but I need him to know the truth. She would have loved and adored him. She would have fed him until he couldn’t move, and they’d listen to their ridiculous Christmas songs, and they would have traded their favorite Christmas movies, and she would have loved that he loves Christmas just as much as she did. Imagining that makes the grief hurt a little less.