Shoved into the corner of a shelf of T-shirts, she spied a white, floppy-eared snowshoe hare. Her breath caught in her throat, and her chest tightened.
She’d forgotten all about that.
“What?” The deep, gravelly voice surprised her. She didn’t know Decker had followed her. “Why’d your face get all…” He made a mopey expression.
She pulled it down. “I used to have one of these. It looked exactly like this.” Her heart raced, and it didn’t make sense. Why was she reacting like this to a toy she’d owned for maybe four days? “I think I was ten the last time I was in this store. Too old for a stuffed animal, but still, I begged my dad for it.”
“Why’d you only have it for a few days?”
“I must’ve lost it at a campsite or something.” Her chest filled uncomfortably with affection for her dad. He’d been so kind. So loving. Never impatient. “He’s a really good guy.”
Oh, my God, you’re not tearing up in this stupid store.
But she was.
It had been a long day, and she still hadn’t recovered from the betrayal. She’d waited nearly eight hours to hear from her mom—that was torture. But she hadn’t gotten an apology. And nothing from Nate or Kendall.
And now that she was on her way home, getting closer to her dad, she could feel herself softening, breaking down.
Which was interesting, wasn’t it? It was like she’d built a partition between the New York version of herself and the Calamity one. One stayed strong and held back emotions, and the other —this one—collapsed at the sight of a stuffed animal that reminded her of the comfort of her dad.
And she needed that. Needed him.
Because he was the one who’d held her every time her mom had canceled her flight or forgotten about a promised phone call.
It was her dad who’d taught her to tie shoes and had gotten the wad of gum out of her hair when she was trying out for cheerleader. It was her dad who’d loved her unconditionally through every season of her life.
Decker’s warm fingers cupped her chin, and she looked at him through a veil of tears. “What’re you thinking?”
“Nothing. It’s just been a rough day.” Pulling away, she shoved the rabbit back on the shelf. “Coffee, tea, or cocoa?”
“Don’t do that. Don’t pretend with me. I can’t stand when people do that. You’re upset. Talk to me.”
“I don’t know.” She let out a deep breath. “I guess this store, this road trip, makes me remember my past. In my busy life, I forgot about these moments.” She gestured at the rabbit. “And they were good, you know? Really good.” She felt stupid crying in front of this successful guy, so she plastered on a smile. “Anyhow, we should get going.”
“It sounds like you have regrets.”
“I guess I do. My dad and I aren’t as close anymore, and that’s on me. I’ve been so driven that I…I guess I left him behind. We used to talk every Sunday night, and I don’t know when that stopped and turned into when I get a chance. He deserves so much better than that.”
He watched her for a moment, as if reading her all the way down to her soul. “In sports psychology, we talk about emotions as mirrors. They show you what’s going on under the surface. Stuff you don’t want to face.” He shifted. “Thing is, if you let yourself feel it, that’s how it loosens. Gets unstuck. And then, you can release it—get it out of your body—and if you want, make amends.” He shoved his hands into the pockets of his worn jeans. “It’s never too late to tell your dad you love him and to make more time for him.”
A crush of warmth for this grumpy quarterback overwhelmed her. “Can I give you a hug?”
He took a step back. “No.”
Chapter Six
Part of Willa was just messing with him, but another part really needed that hug.
He turned all business. “Give me the keys. I’m going to gas up the car so we can get out of here.”
“But your ankle. You can’t drive.”
“I can drive twenty feet to the pumps.”
She slapped the keys in his hand. “Fine. You can be as mean and grumpy as you want, but now I know you’re actually a nice guy.”
“Hurry your ass up.”