“Your hands are freezing,” he murmurs.
“My aunt always said cold hands, warm heart.”
“Warm heart?” Callahan’s chest rumbles against my back with a chuckle. “I think you’d kill me if you could get away with it.”
“My warm heart isn’t that easy to get to these days,” I say. “And I will kill you if you don’t stop disappearing in the middle of the night for booty calls.”
Callahan’s teeth graze my earlobe with a faint growl. “I told you, they’re not booty calls.”
Goosebumps rush to my arms, but I ignore every single one. “And I told you, I don’t care what you’re calling them. I’m not going to be humiliated again by another jock, even if we’re not really dating.”
“I thought you said he didn’t cheat on you.”
I swallow. “He didn’t.”
My fingernails dig into Callahan’s arm when I finally spot Chase. He stands in a group of everyone I used to know, wearing a smile like the devil. His teammates knew why he sought me out and started dating me, but now that I stand here, staring at the throng of them, I’m wondering if everyone knew.
They make their way over to us, and I have to force myself to take deep breaths. Each Alder U hockey player trailing Chase looks from Callahan to me and then back to Callahan. I’m sure they’re wondering if I told Callahan the truth—or anyone, for that matter—but I haven’t. Because Chase is right. I’m not sure who I can trust, and you most definitely won’t catch me trusting a jock ever again.
“Time to play our part, Fireball,” Callahan muses.
“Hey, man.” Jonah, Alder U’s best defenseman, moves in to give Callahan a bro hug, so he’s forced to release his hold on me. The moment there’s space between us, my stomach fills with unease.
Chase keeps his beady stare pinned to me while his teammates practically kiss the ground Callahan stands on, and the longer I try to remain nonchalant and unbothered, the faster my heart beats.
Facing Chase is one thing.
Facing every hockey player from Alder U that participated in the hazing is another.
A chill sweeps through the group, and I shiver. A few girls I recognize from the parties at Alder stand huddled together behind Chase and his friends, staring at me like I’ve done something to them.
I sweep my eyes around the courtyard, desperate for an excuse to leave Callahan’s side. Skye catches my eyes from beside Hayes and a few other teammates of Callahan’s. She turns away from Hayes and very quickly starts heading in my direction. They follow after her, and now the group is three times bigger.
“You were supposed to steal me away,” I whisper when she’s close.
“Instead, I brought backup,” she replies quietly.
“Hey, Adrian.” Jonah throws his fist up for Adrian then moves to Hayes and the other two guys I’ve seen around.
I briefly peek at Callahan with everyone distracted, and he’s gazing directly at me. His eye twitches, and the next thing I know, he has my hand in his. Our fingers intertwine like we’ve held hands a million times. His palm presses to mine, calming me almost instantly.
Hayes clears his throat. “Adrian, didn’t you want to ask Chase something?”
Silence makes its way around the group, and I suddenly can’t breathe again. The muscles along Adrian’s jaw clench, and he bounces his attention from Callahan, to me, to Hayes, and then to Chase.”
“Okay. What?” Chase asks.
Hayes shrugs. “Well, we were having a little debate.”
Chase raises an eyebrow. “About?”
Hayes steps forward. “Why you and our girl Nora here broke up.”
I squeeze Callahan’s hand so hard he makes a noise.
All eyes are on me.
My entire body flushes.