I push into the coffee shop and the bell over the door tings like I’m on stage. It’s busy. A couple people in line. Most already seated. I scan for our signal.
There at a table for two, with a Sea of Thieves guide lined up like a flag, is Sailor Girl.
Her back is to me. Caramel-blonde hair, straight and glossy, falling over a black athletic dress. Even from here her arms scream hours in the pool. I haven’t seen her face, and I’m already half in love with her—already building a life out of the smallest details revealed over late-night gaming.
When a barista walks over to the table and sets down an iced drink, SailorGirl turns her head.
I stop dead in my tracks.
She’s stunning. Blue-green eyes with lashes for days, cheeks warm from the sun, and a heart-shaped mouth that looks like trouble. Then, my gaze drops lower. Long, strong legs crossed under the table, relaxed but powerful, like she knows exactly what her body can do. Heat rolls through me, sharp and undeniable.
Then she smiles.
Real and easy. Like she’s already comfortable here. My heart slams against my ribs, breath hitching, because that smile doesn’t just make her beautiful; it makes her irresistible.
For a second, my focus slips.
I imagine she’s close. Warm and soft and sweet. My hands at her hips, while that laugh I’ve memorized goes softer when I pull her in. The weight of her—real, solid, a perfect fit—settling against me.
Fuck. I want her. Plain and simple.
I take a step forward, my pulse hammering.
And then something catches. A flicker of recognition, sharp and cold beneath the heat. A familiarity that doesn’t come from months of late nights and shared wins online.
I know her.
It takes a beat to place her, and then it hits me like the sting of an ice bath.
Whitney Shields.
Rory’s little sister. Rory—the guy who taught me to love the grind and hate the noise. The guy I disappointed in the ugliest way. The one who turned into a rival after I took a shortcut and carried the fallout alone.
The last time I saw Whitney she was thirteen, maybe fourteen, all braces and bright eyes at a national meet.
She was cute then. Now, she’s devastating.
She thanks the barista, then laughs at something the woman says—head tipped, throat bare—and my stomach pulls tight.
Her gaze drifts toward the door—toward me—and I step sideways into the narrow hallway by the bathrooms. I need a moment to decide if I’m the guy who walks over and detonates the only good thing in his life, or the guy who swallows it and backs away.
It doesn’t take long for me to decide.
I know how this goes.
The second she sees me, it’s over.
She won’t see DreamBoat. She’ll see the guy who burned her brother. The headline version. The one who shows up in photos with different women and never sticks around long enough for anyone to expect more. The flashy, arrogant version Nico’s been selling for years.
And that’s not fair to her.
She didn’t sign up for baggage. She didn’t sign up to reconcile old grudges or sort truth from rumor. She logged on to play a game. To laugh. To feel safe.
Walking over means asking her to carry all of that the second she looks at me.
I won’t do that to her.
I take a breath, then another, like I’m steadying myself on the blocks. My body hates it.