“It felt nautical,” she says, tilting her head. “On brand. Humbling.”
I drag a hand down my face. “Well, it’s not giving me much confidence.”
She scans me up and down, lips twitching. “Trust me, your confidence is just fine.”
She loads the game and chooses a mission, all while giving me a rundown of the basics.
It’s not necessary, because my thumbs immediately know what to do. My focus snaps into place like it’s always been there—strategy, timing, problem-solving—like I can control this, at least.
Whitney watches me like she’s pleased, and it makes my chest squeeze with pride.
“You always take that route?” I ask, already talking trash.
“Yes,” she says. “It’s strategic.”
“It’s reckless.”
“I like danger.”
I glance at her and catch a small smile. “I can tell.”
She kicks my ankle lightly. “Eyes on the screen, Fisk.”
“Yes, ma’am.”
We play and argue and laugh. And get way too competitive.
Somewhere in the middle of it, my guard drops a notch—not enough to be stupid, just enough to forget, for one second, how much I regret not showing up.
The coffee shop flashes through my mind. Her sitting there with an extra chair pulled out, checking the door like she was trying to pretend she didn’t care. I didn’t even give her the decency of an excuse. I told myself I was protecting everyone—that it was better to disappear than to let her see who I was.
But watching her now—bright, animated, and unapologetic—it’s impossible to not picture how that silence must have felt.
My stomach twists.
By the end of the round, we’re shoulder to shoulder, knees touching, arguing over who caused the ship to sink.
“You rammed the dock.”
“You told me to ram the dock,” she says.
“I said approach the dock.”
“Same thing,” she laughs, and the sound does something stupid to my chest.
I find myself staring at her—not just checking her out, though yeah, that, too—but watching her like my brain is filing the moment away. Like I’m collecting proof I’m going to crave later.
Whitney catches me and lifts a brow. “What?”
My mouth opens.
This is it. The moment where I tell her the truth—just the part that matters.
I’m DreamBoat. I’m sorry I didn’t show.
Because every second I don’t tell her, I’m stealing something from her. I’m letting her build a version of me that’s missing the ugliest part. And it makes me a selfish prick.
And the worst part is that I want to keep being selfish.