“Am I?” Aaron raises a dark brow in challenge.
“Yes.” I fold my arms across my chest and glare at him. “Like I already told you, we met once. Nothing happened. And the second I found out who she was, I cut things off before they even started. We haven’t spoken since.”
It was a dick move, but a necessary one. At the time, I was skating on such thin ice with Coach already that pursuing his daughter would’ve ended my Cyclones career. Plus, Caelin probably wouldn’t have even wanted to go out with me again once she realized I was her dad’s least favorite player, and why I held that title.
“Really? Because you’ve got that lovesick puppy look on your face again, Coop.”
“Nah, I was just…thinking about a girl I know who lives here in Vegas.” I waggle my brows. “Might text her later. If she’s lucky.”
“I feel terrible for the poor girl already.” Aaron smirks, but I don’t miss the way his huge shoulders relax. I try not to let his relief sting, because I get it. I’d feel the same if I were in his shoes.
At the beginning of last season, Aaron was made team captain. Around the same time, I had a fling with a sports reporter. It was an impulsive, stupid move on my part to begin with, but everything truly went south when I ended things—and she launched a smear campaign in the media. I wouldn’t have cared so much if she’d publicly dragged only me, but she targeted my teammates, too. Poor Aaron got the worst of it, and it almost cost him his new role. And while he and my teammates didn’t seem to blame me for what happened, I blamed myself.
Coach blamed me, too.
“So you’re sure you’re not going to change your mind about any of this when you see Caelin again tonight at the party?"
Aaron’s looking at me with lingering suspicion in his eyes, and I give my head a shake. I need to stop wallowing and start facing facts. While I’ve never forgotten Caelin, I know I still can’t go there. I’ve learned my lesson that mixing business with pleasure might be okay for the team’s golden boys, but it’s off limits for players like me—and after spending the past year working to prove myself to Coach, I can’t risk undoing that progress. Or letting everyone down again.
So maybe my best move now is to lean into that playboy label the same way I used to. If she sees for herself that I really am a jerk with no substance who’s never going to change his ways, I’ll get ahead of my own lack of forethinking for once. Blow up any kind of a second chance I might’ve still had with her before I’m dumb enough to go after it.
“I’ll be my usual charming self when I see her at the party,” I drawl, swallowing down anything I might be tempted to feel about this decision. What I feel right now doesn’t matter, because I’d rather make Caelin think badly of me than think for a second that me not calling had anything to do with her. She should know she deserves the best.
“Not sure I’d use charming as a descriptor for you,” Aaron fires back.
“Handsome self, then? Or sexy? How about twice-voted Sports Illustrated’s hottest hockey player of the year?”
Aaron rolls his eyes. “Let’s go with incorrigible.”
“Big word, Marino.” I grin. “Did you finally download that word of the day app I told you about?”
“Olivia keeps kicking my ass in Scrabble, so I’m doing everything I can to get an upper hand.” Aaron sighs.
“Never going to happen, she’s way smarter than you, dude.” I take advantage of the subject change and get to my feet, balling my towel at the waist as I stand. “Now let’s go shower already so we can start getting Jimmy drunk.”
I make a break for the showers before Aaron can ask me any more questions about feelings I know I shouldn’t have.
Staying under the hot water for as long as my skin can stand it, I lather my skin with body wash, scrubbing as hard as I can. I’m finally back in Coach’s good graces, where I intend to stay…but no amount of soap can wash away the anticipation that prickles my skin at the thought of seeing Caelin Torres again tonight.
7
CAELIN
I’m lost for words as I look around the fancy, celebrity-chef-owned restaurant. Crystal chandeliers, satin wallpaper… and a colorful array of giant phallic balloons with a banner that reads, “Last Pickle She’ll Ever Tickle.”
“Here’s to the best night we’ll never remember!” Reagan squeals as she pops a bottle of pink champagne. Everyone cheers, me included—but I’m cheering for Reagan and for the fact I wasn’t responsible for these decor decisions. And therefore not accountable if this ends up on an episode of Ramsay’s Kitchen Nightmares.
Lena Anderssen—who’s married to Lars, the team’s hulking Swedish goalie—swipes a cowboy hat from a nearby table and places it atop her head.
“Yoohoo,” she deadpans.
I can’t help but laugh. “Yeehaw, perhaps?”
She shakes her blonde head. “I do not know.”
We’re interrupted with a yell from the groom himself, Jimmy Jones-Johnstone, as he strides into the room wearing full cowboy get-up. “Fear not, ladies, the party has arrived!”
He crosses the room in a few short strides, picks up his bride-to-be, and starts kissing the living daylights out of her. Everyone cheers again.