Page List

Font Size:

Toby’s glare switches from Noelle to me and he shakes his head, but as he shakes, I spot the realization forming in his eyes.

“You remember me, don’t you?” I stand slowly and quickly untie his gag, then drop back to my haunches while he gasps and chokes around the blood that gathered in his mouth from my punches.

“From the grocery store,” he chokes out, slurring his words. Blood drools past his lower lip and he groans. “The fuck are you doing, huh? What the fuck did she tell you? It’s all fucking lies, that’s what it is!”

“No!” Noelle surges forward. “You’re a liar! You’re a fucking liar!”

“Shut the fuck up, bitch!” Toby roars, only to end up choking and gasping when I punch him so hard, my knuckles ache from the blow.

“I have a few ground rules, Tobias. Number one is that you don’t insult my girl in front of me, alright? Number two is that you only speak when I talk to you, and if you can’t manage that, then I’ll cut out your tongue, understand?”

“What the fuck kind of bullshit⁠—”

I’m on him in an instant, throwing myself into his lap and grabbing his jaw with one hand. My other drags one of my many knives from my belt and I thrust the blade into his mouth while squeezing hard at his jaw to force his mouth to remain open.

“Wai— wai— wai⁠—”

“One more word,” I growl out. “Just one more and I will sever your foul fucking tongue right now. I don’t want to do that because it will kill you far too quickly but…” I thrust the knife deeper and the blade cuts through his lower lip. “Don’t fucking test me. Do you understand?”

Toby stares at me with wide, wild eyes, and a full-body tremor moves through him.

“You can talk now.”

“Yes,” he croaks out around the knife pressed against his tongue. “I understand.”

“Good.” Removing the knife, I twirl it around in my fingers as I stand and pat his cheek. “Now, do you know why you’re here?”

Toby’s head sags forward slightly and he pants heavily. “Her lies.”

“Lies?” I tsk softly. “We both know that’s not true. You kidnapped Noelle and her friend, didn’t you? Snatched them right off the street and held them for three days where you raped, tortured, and then killed poor Anne. You were going to do the same to Noelle, weren’t you?”

Toby lifts his head, and his eyes dart between me and where Noelle hovers behind me.

“No,” he croaks. “The j-jury acquitted me.” His bleeding lips pull into a cold smile. “I’m innocent.”

“Fuck off, do you really think I give a shit what the court says? I’m the law here, you understand? And you know what my judgment is?” I glance over my shoulder at Noelle.

She stands with her hands clasped together at her chest, her eyes wide and her lips parted as she watches in a mix of awe and horror.

“I don’t give a fuck about your judgment,” Toby mumbles between the blood trailing out of his mouth. “I’ll have you both fucking a-arrested.”

“You’re cocky for a man who got away with so much. In my world, you never would have seen a trial date. Two years you’ve lived convincing yourself that you did nothing wrong, but do you want to know something?” I wander closer to Toby and he flinches away, then lifts his head as I start walking around him. “You sold Anne’s kidney. Do you know who controls the black market organs? Who decides where they go, who handles the money, and who deals with the heat? People from my world. Now I couldn’t track Anne’s kidney because it’s been years, but what I could do is show your picture around to see if anyone recognized you. After what Noelle told me and what I read in the court proceedings, I had to verify for myself. And do you know what I found?”

I stop behind him and lock eyes with Noelle while leaning down and bringing my lips to Toby’s ear.

“People knew you. Wasn’t the first time you’d sold some poor girl’s organ, was it?”

Noelle’s eyes widen further and one hand flies over her mouth.

“Bullshit,” Toby chokes out. “Fucking bullshit!”

“So here’s what I’m going to do. Everything you did to Anne? Everything you did to Noelle?” My voice drops to a whisper. “I’m going to do that to you, Toby. Every single thing. We’ll see how fucking cocky you are after all that.”

After an injection of adrenaline to keep him awake and alert, I start with the waterboarding, using a bucket and a hosepipe from the rear of the warehouse. It washes away a lot of the blood from his earlier beating but thanks to his busted teeth and broken nose, Toby almost gurgles his last breath multiple times while I hold him under and slam my fist into his gut like he did to Noelle. Each time he’s dragged up for air, I break a finger until he has no working fingers left and his struggles against the ropes become almost comically desperate.

His clothes end up in a pile on the floor, and I let Noelle burn them with lighter fluid and matches, something she enjoys, judging by the smile that crosses her face when the flames ignite. Toby tries to beg me and persuade me that Noelle is a liar, so I break his wrists next, mirroring her own broken wrist during her escape.

He still insists he did nothing wrong.


Novels you may like ...