Page List

Font Size:

1

NOELLE

“We find the defendant, Tobias Clarke, not guilty.”

Not Guilty.

Those two words fly across the courtroom and hit me with the force of a physical punch to the chest while cheers rise up from the defendant’s table. Toby stands and draws his lawyer into a tight hug, laughing and shaking him back and forth as they celebrate.

Not Guilty?

How the fuck can they say not guilty?

“Jury, the State of New York thanks you for your service. Tobias Clarke?” The judge adjusts his glasses and clears his throat. “You are free to go. Please do so with this court’s apologies.”

Apologies?

What the fuck do they have to apologize for? They should be apologizing to me for failing to lock up such a monster.

Not guilty? It’s impossible.

Rage unlike anything I’ve ever felt before ignites in my chest like lava and my next breath escapes in a short gasp. Every muscle tightens, every limb quakes, and I’m forced to sit there as Toby celebrates his newfound freedom.

Tears prick at the corners of my eyes and I glance across to the twelve jury members as they filter out of the courtroom.

Did they not listen to my testimony? Were they not moved by the officer crying on the stand over the state I was found in? How cold are their fucking hearts?

I’m on my feet, chasing after Christopher, the Assistant District Attorney, who assured me this was an open and shut case.

He strides out of the courtroom, not even sparing me a glance while I weave through spectators and onlookers who wear expressions a hundred times more sympathetic than that fucking jury.

“Chris!” I catch his elbow just beyond the doors leading to the hallway. “What the hell happened?”

Chris stops with a short, sharp sigh and faces me while adjusting his spotted tie. “You heard the verdict the same as I did, Noelle. There’s nothing more I can do.”

“But they said not guilty! How is that even possible? You told me—” A wry glance from an uptight onlooker forces me to lower my voice. “You told me this was one of the easiest cases you’d ever taken. You told me that these past two years were going to be worth it today and he was going to prison for the rest of his life!” I prod him hard on his stupid tie. “You said that!”

“And you lied to me,” Chris hisses, grabbing my elbow. He pulls me out of the middle of the hallway and toward one of the outer walls. “You didn’t tell me about the drugs, or all the men you’d been dating in the lead up to your time with him. Do you have any idea how bad that made you look on the stand?”

“Excuse me?” My entire body trembles as if my joints are about to break and scatter my limbs across the floor. It would be a damn sight less painful than this. “I told you those drugs were planted. I’ve never done anything like that in my life, and my dating history shouldn’t matter when a monster like that targeted me. Targeted—” I choke on her name and hot tears flood my eyes, but I refuse to let them fall.

“It made you look unreliable,” Chris says flatly. “Juries don’t react well to promiscuous women. It’s unfair, but that’s just how it is. And you couldn’t prove those drugs were planted.”

“Are you stupid?” I bark at him. “How exactly am I supposed to prove I didn’t do something when there’s no proof that I didn’t buy anything? I offered to take every test under the sun and you said no. And hold on, three different men is promiscuous?”

“To them, yeah.” Chris sighs deeply and steps back, dragging a hand over his face. “Look… I can’t rule out that the jury was spoiled, but proving that is more impossible than anything else. I’m sorry, Noelle. Unless there’s something else he’s done that you want to try him on… it’s over.”

I clutch at my hips, digging my fingernails into my flesh to try and control the tremble. “Spoiled? What does that mean?”

“Tobias had a good defense lawyer,” Chris replies. “Sometimes… juries see things or hear things outside of court that they’re not supposed to.”

For a moment, my heart stops. A cunt like Toby absolutely would do anything to get free, so I wouldn’t put it past him, but that doesn’t ease the sickness in my gut.

“Isn’t it your job to make sure that doesn’t happen? To make sure the trial remains fair? I got on that stand and I spent hours telling them everything he did to me, everything he did to her, and that’s not enough? How are you going to sleep at night knowing you let a monster like that back on the streets?”

Chris’s brows twitch slightly and he sighs deeply, taking another step back. “I’m sorry, Noelle. We tried and we lost. There’s nothing more we can do.”

Nothing more.


Novels you may like ...