As I stand here for a few seconds longer, I realize that, for the first time in years, the noise doesn’t feel like something I have to endure. It feels like something I’ve missed. Wylie catches me watching him and raises his eyebrows like he’s asking what I’m looking at. Then he smiles, and I feel it in my chest.
I push off the doorway and carry the vegetables to the table before I do something stupid, like walk over and kiss him in front of everyone.
Dinner is loud, messy, and better than I expected. My sister makes a toast to family, my brother complains that nobody appreciates his cooking, and the ranch hands trade stories about the strangest things they’ve seen on the property. Wylie listens to everyone with genuine interest. He asks questions, remembers names, and makes room for people who might otherwise get talked over.
It’s such a small thing, but I notice.
I notice everything about him these days.
The way he leans toward someone when they’re speaking. The way he laughs without checking whether anyone else is laughing first. The way he offers to clear plates before anyone asks for help. He’s good at making people feel welcome, and I can’t help but wonder what it would be like to have that in my life beyond a few weeks.
I allow myself to imagine next Christmas. Wylie could be sitting right there, like he is now. He’d probably steal ham from the platter again. He’d tease my brother about his stories, help the kids hang ornaments on the tree, and make some smart remark about my mother’s insistence on cooking enough food for an entire country. Maybe he’d even be here in the morning, drinking coffee with me before everyone else woke up. Maybe he’d complain about the cold while I fed the horses. Maybe he’d—
No. I stop myself before I can finish that sentence.
My fork rests halfway to my mouth. Next Christmas. I’ve spent years trying not to think beyond the next bill, the next season, the next problem that needs fixing. Planning for a future is usually a matter of numbers and maintenance schedules.
But for one naive moment, I picture it with Wylie. The realization frightens me enough that I take a long drink of water and focus on my breathing. Across the table, Wylie catches my eye. His gaze softens, and I wonder whether he can somehow tell what I’ve been thinking. Then my nephew asks him another question, and Wylie turns back to the conversation, while I tell myself that I’m allowed to enjoy tonight without making it mean anything.
It’s a lie, but it’s all I’ve got.
After dinner, the younger kids insist on opening the small gifts we’ve set aside for everyone. The ranch hands gather near the tree, and somebody produces a box of old ornaments that belonged to my parents.
My sister holds up a wooden star with a chip on one of the points. “Dad made this one,” she says.
The room goes quiet.
I remember him at the kitchen table, carving the star while Mom supervised from over by the stove. He’d been terrible at following instructions, and the thing had come out lopsided. Mom loved it anyway.
Taking it from my sister, I turn it over in my hands. “We used to put this on the tree first.” My voice sounds strange to my own ears.
“Every year,” my sister says softly.
I look at the tree. The lights blur slightly, and I blink until they come back into focus. For years, I’ve avoided this part of Christmas. The traditions that make Dad’s absence impossible to ignore. The empty space where his chair used to be. The stories that remind me of everything I can never get back.
“Where does it go?” Wylie asks beside me, holding out a length of ribbon.
Looking at the star in my hand, I say, “Top of the tree.”
“Then let’s get it up there.”
He doesn’t ask whether I’m all right, doesn’t tell me my father would want me to be happy. He simply stands beside me while I fix the star on the top branch. When I step back, Wylie slips his hand into mine behind the tree, hidden from everyone else. I squeeze his fingers, and it feels like the biggest thing I’ve done all evening.
Around nine, the ranch hands head home, my siblings collect their children and leftovers, and the house slowly returns to its normal quiet. Wylie helps me carry the remaining dishes to the kitchen, then steps outside to retrieve his phone from his coat. I hear the buzz before I see him. He looks at the screen, and something shifts in his expression. It’s barely noticeable—a small tightening around the eyes, a pause—but I notice.
“Everything okay?” I ask.
He slips the phone into his pocket and nods. “Yeah. Just an email.”
“From who?” I have no right to be so nosy, but the question comes before I realize what I’m saying.
“Someone I used to work with.” I glance at Wylie. He’s rubbing the back of his neck, looking unusually uncomfortable. “There’s a job opening in Colorado. A full-time position. Good money, a training program of my own. They asked if I’d be interested.”
For a moment, I can’t process the words.
Colorado.
Full-time.