But if he was desperate or invested, he wouldn't have seen that.
"We dated for years. Things were good. I thought they were good, at least. She was increasingly unhappy, though. Things had to be done a certain way. I rarely did them right. Couldn't read her mind. I was gone a lot because of hockey, too. The situation wasn't healthy. I didn't realize it, then. Jude and King rarely saw us interact, so they didn't understand the dynamics."
"Do they understand, now?"
"No. What was I going to say? Cora had high expectations that I couldn't meet? I fucked everything up? I couldn't read her mind?" He shook his head. "They don't get it. And I let it go on way too long. She was the one who ended it, two years into my career. She said it was because I still wasn't ready to have kids, and I finally realized that her reluctance never had anything to do with that."
I grimaced. "I'm sorry."
"It's my fault. I should've realized the relationship was fucked up."
"How long ago was it?"
"More than a decade ago. I shouldn't still be awkward. Every time I think I'm over it, I have another conversation with a stranger, and fuck everything up." He sounded frustrated.
"Have you been with anyone since her?"
"No. Which is why Jude is convinced that seeing her again would fix things. He thinks I'm still in love with her."
"Are you?"
"No. I'm just fucking awkward." He flung a hand toward the fake hockey players on the screen. "If I had someone hitting on me despite my awkwardness, like that, maybe I could get the fuck over it."
"There are a ton of puck bunnies who would be all over you if you let them, Hollis. You're the hottest guy on the team."
He gave me an incredulous look. "You don't actually think that."
"What motivation do I have to lie? You broke into my house, looked at my vibrator like it was a bomb, and refused my popcorn after calling me sad."
"I brought chocolate, though."
I laughed. "Yeah, because that fixes everything else."
"Calling you sad isn't an insult. Everyone has emotions."
"I wish I had less of them."
"Plenty of werewolves wish that."
I nodded. "Carmen struggled a lot, before she got with King. Sex is the best outlet. I'm just in a dry spell."
"How could you possibly be in a dry spell?"
Before the conversation we were currently having, I would've thought he was insulting me. Now, I knew him better than that.
"Are you complimenting me again?" I asked, just to make sure.
"Of course I am. You could have any man you wanted." He gestured toward me.
"Have you tried dating recently? No one wants a relationship, or even a friendship. They just want sex. It's annoying, but I need to feel a connection to someone before I can fuck them. Unfortunately, no one wants to be fuck buddies, because of the risk of a mate bond. And no one is willing to risk someone catching feelings for them by having a real conversation with them, either."
"Fuck the surface level shit. That's why I haven't been with any of the puck bunnies. They don't care about who I am—they only care that I'm a hockey player."
"Exactly." I lifted a hand toward Hollis emphatically. "You get it. We're chill."
"So chill," he agreed.
"I wish there was something we could do about it," I admitted. "It would be nice to have what Carmen and King have. They're so happy."