“You will be hearing shit when you dab the grease off,” she told him. “It’s the best part. How else are you supposed to know if it’s high-quality pizza?”
Elias shook his head. “How are you a doctor?”
She shrugged. “I’m a vet. I don’t think dogs should eat the grease. But life is too short to deny simple pleasures.”
Elias gave her a look. “You regularly give Moose your crust.”
She looked offended. “Okay, you know I hate the crust and he loves it. He’s a good boy. This is a win-win.”
From his spot on the ground, Moose let out a small bark, as if agreeing with Claire. Claire gave Elias a shit-eating grin. Try as he might, Elias never figured out how the two of them were always able to gang up on him despite being different species.
After a second, Claire’s playful expression turned more serious. “You look like shit, big brother.”
“You really know how to make a man feel good about himself, you know,” Elias said.
“Elias. Are you ready to talk about it?” she asked finally.
He wasn’t sure he was ready, but he knew telling her that probably wouldn’t go over too well. She would get the answer out of him one way or another.
“I guess I have to be. I had a fight with Nolan,” he said, and it felt like a weight was lifted off his shoulders. “He posted a picture of Moose and it was so obvious he was here late. I asked him to delete it, because I don’t want people to get the wrong idea.”
Claire gave him a look. “The wrong idea like he’s your boyfriend?”
Elias groaned. “Don’t say it like that.”
Claire raised an eyebrow. “How should I say it then? Or is he not your boyfriend anymore?”
“Of course he’s still my boyfriend,” Elias rushed to say, but he realized there wasn’t really an “of course” about it. This easily could be a relationship-ending event.
“Good to know. Back to the issue,” Claire said. She had never been known for her subtlety.
“I don’t want people talking. I don’t want my whole career to just be about me being gay, Claire. My sexuality shouldn’t matter,” he told her.
She nodded. “What did he say when you told him that? Wait, you did tell him that, right?”
“Yes, I told him that. He said he thinks people will care more about the fact that I’m a good player than the fact that I’m gay. But he’s young, Claire, he hasn’t been in the league that long. The media fucking loves a headline. They’ll latch onto it and make me the poster boy for league inclusion. I don’t want that. I just wanna play hockey.”
Claire took a deep breath. “I’m gonna ask you something. And I want you to think about it. Don’t immediately answer. I really want you to think about it first.” Elias braced himself. Claire continued, “You said you just want to play hockey. Are you okay with just playing hockey if the price of that is losing Nolan?”
It felt like the wind had been knocked out of his chest. For a second, Elias tried to imagine his life without Nolan. He tried to picture more Cups, retiring with the Royals, becoming a hall-of-famer. He imagined doing it without Nolan.
It fucking sucked.
He didn’t want any of it if it meant not having Nolan.
“There it is,” Claire whispered.
Elias suddenly felt more panicky than he had a few minutes ago. “But I still don’t want to come out,” he told her desperately.
Claire shrugged. “Then don’t. Is that what he’s asking of you?”
Elias shook his head. “No, but…it’s pretty much the same thing, right? He wants to post about being together.”
Claire reached forward and squeezed his leg. “It’s not, though. You can have a relationship without making it a thing. Think about how many celebrities have relationships where they just exist without explicitly confirming it. And if an A-list celebrity can do it, so can you. No offense, but you are not at the same level as Taylor Swift.”
Elias knew that, logically. But emotionally, it felt like if he gave an inch, they would take a mile.
Claire must have recognized his internal debate was still going on. So, she said, “Elias, I’m not asking you to decide whether you’re right. I’m asking you to decide what’s worth losing.”