Page 26 of Butterfly Proposal

Page List

Font Size:

The corners of his lips pull up on one side as he digs through a drawer and pulls out a corkscrew. “I’d rather you drink it. If you knew my sister, you’d know why.”

“That doesn’t sound good.”

He shrugs. “Lucia is fine. She gets off on being a pain in my ass. She’s twelve years older than me and acts like my second mother. I have another sister, Elena, but she lives in Montana and has enough kids of her own to take care of without worrying about how I live my life.”

I set my purse on the coffee table, slide my cell into my back pocket, and walk to the big island across from where he’s uncorking Lucia’s bottle of red. “I’m an only child. I’ll never understand the sibling dynamic.”

He opens a cabinet for a wine stem and serves me a heavy-handed pour. “Lucia can be cool. She just takes great pleasure in micromanaging everyone’s life. Keeping her glass full and letting her think she’s in charge is easier than arguing with her.”

He slides me my pre-dinner drink and goes back to the fridge. I take a sip as he unwraps chicken from butcher paper and cracks eggs into a shallow bowl. With my glass of red in my hand, I let him do his thing while I wander around the great room. The art is eclectic, the pictures are evidence that Dean is telling the truth about his family, and the knickknacks aren’t anything I’d ever expect a man like him would own, let alone display in his house.

I pick up a worn hardcover book that’s been read so many times the corners are frayed. Opening it, I’m surprised to see that it’s a first edition.

“Buckskin Brigades.” Turning to find Dean dredging chicken breasts in flour, egg, and breadcrumbs, I hold up the book. “This seems unusual for an Army man.”

He barely looks up from his task. “It was one of my dad’s. Do you read?”

“Not really. I have to study so many scripts, I rarely have time to pick up a book for enjoyment. Maybe I should. It might be good for me to get lost in someone else’s story. Do you?”

He moves to the sink to wash his hands. “Rarely.”

I hold up the copy of Buckskin Brigades that looks as worn as the wood floors. “Have you read this?”

He dries his hands, tosses the towel to the counter, and stalks around the island. He stares down at the book in my hands for a heavy moment before his gaze shifts to me. “I’ve read that one more than once. Have you heard of it?”

I shake my head. “No. I wish I was deep and poetic. I can’t even pretend to be.”

“Why would you pretend to be something you’re not?”

I huff a laugh and shake my head. “That’s quite literally my job, Dean.”

“You know what I mean.”

I ignore that, set my wine down, and open the front cover. I’m about to flip through the book, but I don’t get past the interior title page.

Dean,

Be a good man in an imperfect world.

Always choose honor.

Love,

Dad

My heart clenches at the inscription, and I start to put the book down. "I’m sorry. I’m intruding into your private life.”

He reaches out to stop me, and I freeze when his fingers brush mine. “I invited you here, Effie. Feel free to intrude.”

I bite my lip, knowing I should put the book down, but after reading the inscription, I can’t make myself do it. Instead, I start to turn the pages. “There are penciled notes all over the margins.”

“My dad liked to put his thoughts down about books. Sometimes he argued with them. It was his personality. I’m not sure he was deep and poetic, but he liked to challenge his mind.”

I run my fingertips down the margin of one of the heavily annotated pages before I look up at Dean. “Liked?”

“We lost him four years ago. It was sudden, not that there’s an easy way to lose someone you love. There’s not. But one day he was healthy and riding his land after work, and the next he was gone. Mom found him collapsed in the bathroom. He had a heart attack. He was only seventy-one.”

Carefully closing the book, I set it back on the table where it was lovingly displayed, and not just randomly left to pick up later. I find myself wanting to reach out to touch him, but don’t, crossing my arms and hugging my middle instead. “I’m sorry. No one’s pain is the same, so I’d never say I can relate. There’s always something shallow or off-putting about that.”


Novels you may like ...