"I'm not arguing about whether they deserved it," he says. "I want that clear, because I think you're braced for it. I decided that part in their kitchen when Wolfe handed me a beer, and I decided it again at their card table. I don't have the reaction. It never came."
"Then what?"
"Who checks your work?"
I don't have one single thing for that.
"There's a woman in Bayonne," he says. "Her name is Denise. Her son is Eddie and he called her every Sunday for nine years. One Sunday he didn't, so she drove over and let herself in with her own key and his keys were sitting on the counter. She requested his phone records herself, because nobody was going to do it for her. She keeps them in a shoebox."
The basement has gone very quiet.
"She told me I was the first person who ever asked her for any of it." He looks up at me. "You've known what happened to Eddie for four months. You've known the entire time. And it has never once occurred to you to drive to New Jersey."
And he's right. It hadn't. It had not entered my head one time in four months.
"That's the part," he says. "Not the arithmetic. Nobody writes any of it down and nobody drives to Bayonne, and you decide which nineteen on your own in a truck."
"It isn't nineteen," I say, because it's the only true thing I have left.
"I know," he says. "You just told me. You knew how to get into my house, where I lived. How I liked my coffee. How?”
“Well, you see.” I rub the back of my head, grimacing when I realize there's more blood being rubbed into my hair. “At first, I wanted to see what you were up to after you came into my bar. I knew you were working on something that had close ties to what I was doing, so I started following you. But, then I quickly became infatuated with you. You were putting yourself at risk with how you were conducting your research for your article and the idea of you getting hurt made me uneasy, so I kept following you to make sure you were safe.”
“So, you stalked me?” he asks, raising a brow.
"Just a little bit." I hold up my finger and thumb.
He takes something out of his coat pocket and holds it up. A bar napkin, folded in half, gone soft at the crease from sitting in a drawer.
"You wrote this at my desk."
"I did."
Then he takes out the other one, and my stomach goes out from under me, because I know which one that is before he has it all the way open.
"And you wrote this one sitting in my bedroom while I was unconscious two feet away from you."
"Yes."
"Why block capitals?"
Of all the things he could have led with. "So you couldn't match the handwriting."
"Mm," he says. "You did it twice."
"I know."
"You wrote me a note in a disguise, and then you wrote me a second one in the same disguise and handed it to me in daylight." He folds them both and puts them away. "I'd have gotten there eventually. I want you to know that."
"Baby, you got there."
“Did you take me home the night I was drugged?” he asks. “Because one moment I was at the bar, the next I’m waking up in my bed. No one else would have known where I lived.”
"Yes," I tell him. "I knew something wasn't right the second I looked at you. I had him out the back door and into a dumpster before he ever touched you. I got you home and then I went back for him."
"You killed him."
"I did."