“I go at least once a month. It’s such a nice change of pace from working in a hectic kitchen.”
When I first spoke to Talia, she said she thought my fishing was a green flag. Now I understood why. I’d rarely met anyone who was into sitting silently in nature for hours, let alone another gay man my age. She likely knew that he’d had the same experience.
“What’s your favorite spot around here?” I asked.
“Grand Lake. It’s quite a drive from here, but it’s the best.”
“I love Grand Lake! That’s actually where I went swimming.”
“I knew it!” He slapped his free hand on the table. “That’s where I pictured it happening!” His fingers curled around mine. “Okay, now I really need to say it: I so wanna go fishing with you.”
“Making plans for a second date already?” Not that it sounded bad to me. On the contrary. I was totally up for it. But weren’t we getting ahead of ourselves? We hadn’t even finished dinner.
“If it’s even half as fun as this one, it will be the best fishing trip ever.” His fingers moved faster now, caressing me as if the excitement of discovering our shared interest needed somewhere to go. “I mean it. I’ll be leaving Wednesday for two weeks, but we could set something up when I get back.”
“Won’t it still be a little too cold to go fishing?”
“Why? Are you not into ice fishing?”
“After falling into the water once, I’m not exactly eager to do it again when it’s freezing.”
“Okay, fair. But the risk of going for an involuntary swim in winter is super low. Especially when you’re going with a seasoned pro like me.”
“A chef and a pro fisherman?”
“Not to brag, but I worked as a fishing instructor the summer after high school before I started at The Beefsteak Factory. So believe me when I tell you you’re totally missing out if you don’t go ice fishing with me. The crisp air? The serene silence? Wrapping yourself in a blanket with a mug of cocoa in your hand? It’s the best.”
Somehow I pictured us together under the same blanket. “When you put it like that, it does sound quite nice.”
“That’s what I’m saying!”
“Remind me to give you my number once this is over.”
“Tell me now. I’m so excited, I’ll memorize it.” His voice trembled with joy. “I’m kidding, though. My memory is shit when it comes to numbers.”
His fingers crept over my wrist, brushing the cuff of my sweater like they wanted to go further. I couldn’t blame him. My chest fluttered so wildly, I wanted to feel more of him, too. I slid my hand past his wrist and over his forearm. My fingertips trailed through the fine hairs peeking out of his shirt cuff. Nico froze for a second, then eagerly copied me.
“What else do you like to do in your free time?” he asked, still enthusiastic.
“Nothing too spectacular. I spend a lot of time outdoors. I enjoy hiking or going to the beach in the summer. Love a good movie or book. And cooking, of course. Although I’m likely not as good as you.”
“I can cook for you, and you’ll be the judge.”
The way he just kept on making plans made me chuckle.
“What about you?” I asked.
“Similar things. I’m not a big reader, but movies, fishing, and hiking all sound like a day well spent to me. I also love to sleep in and have breakfast in bed and cuddle under a blanket.”
“That’s not a hobby.”
“Ha! I’ll show you how much of a hobby that can be.” He wrapped his fingers around my palm, no hesitation left. He squeezed it hard, like he was sealing the deal so I couldn’t back out anymore. Not that I wanted to. We shared so many interests that it was almost ridiculous. “Oh, and I’m really into theme parks. If it’s got anything close to a roller coaster, I’m in.”
“There we have it. That’s the one thing that doesn’t line up,” I said as if the whole point of our conversation was to find things that we didn’t have in common. “I’m a total scaredy-cat when it comes to stuff like that.”
“Is that a deal breaker?”
“Only if you want to get married on a roller coaster.”