Jennie climbed down a few rungs, clanging the trapdoor shut over her head. She felt Miles’s hands on her waist, guiding her down to the ground, reminding her of what life would be like once they found the diamond, once Maurice was behind bars. Never in her wildest dreams had she imagined a future so rare and golden.
Miles explored the subterranean space with the light’s beam. They were at the short end of a corridor that ran parallel to the market above. One side was a flat stone wall, the other a series of arched alcoves. Other than a wisp of breeze traveling through some unseen vent, the air was heavy, still, and cold. Jennie walked to the end and found the passage was stopped up with a very solid brick wall.
Miles followed her. “Is this a dungeon?” he asked, not at all joking.
Jennie tried to remember what she’d read at the library. “It was originally built to store illegal weapons during the Cuban revolution. But the mausoleum letter said that later, when the Porters owned it, they decorated it for a ball, and one alcove had a fortune teller in it. That’s the one we need to find. The one where Marcella Porter said she left the diamond.”
“How do we tell which room that was?” asked Miles.
Jennie grabbed the light and pointed it into the alcove nearest to the brick wall. She jumped, stifling a scream, and dragged Miles down to the ground with her.
“What? What is it?”
When no horrible thing flew out, Jennie shined her light back into the alcove and swore.
“It’s a mirror,” she breathed. She went up closer to it and saw the surface of the glass was waved. “A goddamn funhouse mirror. Sorry. It scared the shit out of me.”
Miles came up beside her and ran his finger along the glass surface. A bright line showed through a layer of dust. “I don’t think anybody’s been down here for a long time,” he said.
She moved the light along the floor and saw a small drain in the center, the source of the draft. The faint sound of running water and an unpleasant note of sewage wafted out of it.
They went together into the next alcove. An entire dead tree, entombed in cobwebs, leaned in the corner. Something crunched under Miles’s foot, and he jumped aside. Jennie aimed the light at it, and something shiny winked back. She picked it up.
“What is it?” he asked.
“It’s a piece of costume jewelry,” she said, eyeing the corroded metal and clouded glass cabochon.
“Not a diamond, then?” said Miles.
“Not quite.” She put it in her pocket anyway.
In the next alcove, a haphazard pile of leftover construction materials. Bricks and two-by-fours and scaffold pipes.
“Anything reading as ‘Fortune Teller’ to you?” said Miles.
“Not yet.” Jennie pointed the light toward the black archway of the final alcove. Inside, a round wooden frame, its interior divided in a radial pattern.
“It looks like it was a stained glass window,” said Miles.
“You’re right—like a miniature rose window.”
“What’s a rose window?”
“You know, the circular windows on the front of cathedrals?”
“Like on Notre Dame?”
“Exactly—Oh! Miles!—in The Hunchback of Notre Dame, the character Esmeralda is a fortune teller. This must be it!”
He took the light, methodically sweeping it across the room. “Okay. Let’s clean out the space and see what we find.”
They rolled away the broken window frame and cleared loose boards and piles of vintage cigarette butts. When the alcove was bare, they swept the light across again. Nothing. Stone walls and slate floor.
“We have to check inside the walls,” said Jennie.
Miles ran his hand across his brow, leaving behind a smudge of dirt. “I’m going to say something—don’t be mad—but how do we know somebody else didn’t find the diamond a long time ago?”
“We don’t,” Jennie admitted. “But I just—I don’t think anybody else has found it. I can’t explain. The box was waiting for me for a hundred years. The universe wouldn’t let us go on a damn treasure hunt from Brooklyn to the Bronx for nothing, would it?”