“It says Not Safe.”
“What isn’t safe?”
“I don’t know. Maybe he suspected Maurice? But also the Midnight Diamond is supposed to be cursed. Anybody who touches it has really bad things happen to them. The duke who owned it, the one who commissioned the box, drowned, and then his family was basically erased from history by World War One. Maybe Pete thought—”
“Curses aren’t real,” Miles said quickly. “Peter was eccentric, but he didn’t seem . . . superstitious.”
“You’re right,” Jennie agreed. “He wasn’t. But now he’s dead. So. He wasn’t worried about nothing.”
They sat in silence until Jennie said, “What do we do now . . . we go to the cops, right?”
Miles cleared his throat. “I don’t know—I may have inadvertently tipped off Maurice that we’re onto him.”
“But I wasn’t even onto him until right now. Not really, I mean.”
“When I couldn’t find a record of the locket in my paperwork, I thought there had to be some mistake. I—I felt awful, about yesterday morning. If this was the reason you and I were fighting, I needed to understand. So I asked him about it, and he became annoyed and defensive and we just looked at each other and I could see in his eyes that he knew I knew.”
“So what did you do?”
“I left.”
“Shit.”
“And then I got a call from my boss at the messenger company.”
“And?”
“And you’re not the only one who’s been fired. Maurice told them I’d been stealing.”
“Oh, Miles. I’m so sorry. What did you do?”
“I called you and came here. I knew you were the only one who would believe me. I can’t believe I worked for that asshole for two years.”
She reached out and took his hand. He squeezed hers back. “I have an idea,” she said. “How we can get back at him.”
“Is it to turn him into the police for murder?”
“That. But before, there’s something else. He told me he’s been searching for the Midnight Diamond for years. What if we found it first?”
Miles turned toward her. “Do you know where it is? You told me yesterday morning you’d only just heard of it.”
“That was true. But I went to the NYPL archives after Lee fired me. I found some information I don’t think Maurice has. Something I don’t think anybody still living knows about. I think the diamond might be in a mausoleum at Green-Wood Cemetery.”
“You mean buried in a grave?”
“Not exactly.” She explained about the architect’s note. “It sounded like the last owner might have given the stone its own special altar. It would be above ground, enclosed in a stone monument.”
Miles nodded. “Okay . . .”
“And if we go to the cops about Maurice right now, the story of the Midnight will blow up. Everybody will be looking for it.”
Miles continued to nod. “But if we find it first . . .”
“Then we could keep it for ourselves and nobody would have to know. You said you were working to help your mom out, right? A diamond like this is worth millions. But we have to be quick. Maurice is searching for it. And there’s a possibility Lee might be as well.”
“Okay,” he said. “Okay. But how do we get into the mausoleum without anyone seeing us?”
“I’m so glad you asked. It just so happens, that there’s a midnight party tonight in the cemetery. And I have two tickets. And one of them already has your name on it . . . I’d meant to ask you there on a date.”