“And . . .” said Marcella, displaying a ruby ring from a gentleman admirer on her finger, “I think I will make a habit of selling these gifts to supplement our income. I don’t want a man to think he has a hold on me, if he sees me wearing his present.”
“Good.”
“But first, I’m going to buy a little scale and a loupe. And with your knowledge of gemstones, we can decide how much something ought to be worth before I go to Maiden Lane, so we don’t get fleeced.”
Anneke flinched when Marcella said “Maiden Lane.” The last place her friend had seen Aldert. After Marcella had written to him, telling him to stay away from Anneke, he’d sent only one line in response: As my lady wishes, though it breaks my heart.
“It is a good plan,” the Dutchwoman said resolutely, “to sell these things. You inherited your father’s knack for business.”
“I think it comes from my mother, actually,” said Marcella.
With her own money safely growing in an account that had only her name on it, Marcella felt a sense of confidence and security she had never known in her prior life. She decided she was ready to lean even further into her new, actress persona, and take a lover.
The chorus girls showed her how everything was done so she wouldn’t find herself “in a situation.” She chose a young man (but not too young, said the chorus girls, “You want to make sure he knows what he’s doing”) in town on business from San Francisco. And boy, did he know what he was doing. He took her to the opera, to Sherry’s, to Tiffany & Co, and then he took her to bed at the Waldorf-Astoria and neither of them got up for two days except to open the door for the man who brought the wine. Marcella had to rush out to make her evening performance. When she finally returned to her own suite after the show, there were two dozen red roses and a note that said if she was ever in San Francisco she ought to look him up.
“Men,” she told Anneke, burying her face in the flowers, “are much more fun when you don’t try to marry them.”
Anneke, who after all had been engaged, was more experienced in these sorts of things and had jumped right into the overnight portion with their gentlemen admirers. She laughed at her friend’s discovery of an old truth. “I’m happy for you, Cella. It’s nice, isn’t it, to be with a man like that?” She paused and said, more quietly, “When I am with another, for a moment at least, I am not thinking of him.”
Marcella looked up. “Do you miss him, still? I didn’t realize—”
The Dutchwoman bit her lip. “I’ve been too embarrassed to speak of it. But these . . . distractions . . . are helpful. They keep me from going to him. I know it’s pathetic—”
“It’s not,” said Marcella. “Remember what you told me back on that awful ship? You told me that ‘Love is not something that can be helped.’ She wondered now, seeing her friend’s woeful expression, if she’d been right to interfere. To encourage the alienation of two people rather than their reconciliation. But she brushed off the thought. The diamond wouldn’t have let her make a bad decision. Even if the path it had sent her on was anything but straightforward, never had she felt so free, so happy. So herself. She was sure Anneke would arrive there, in time.
After a hot bath, Marcella collapsed into her bed in contented exhaustion. She stretched her toes out in the soft, cool sheets, stroking the Midnight where it was pinned to her nightdress. Her eyes closed, and she was surprised to find she was onstage, in the spotlight. She was up to her ankles in lilies and pearls. In front of her, the theater was overfull, with aisles packed and people standing upon their seats. Every man and woman was applauding, clapping so hard their hands were red, tears of admiration streaming down their face, crying encore!
“What encore?” Marcella asked. She couldn’t remember the song she’d been singing. She turned to the chorus girls, but they just stared at her, hands clasped in adoration, nodding for her to continue. Marcella realized her own hands were poised upon the laces of her gown. She pulled a string and her bodice loosened. The applause grew even wilder, fists pounding on tables, hats thrown in the air. She knew what they wanted now. She pulled the strings out of the first row of eyelets. That ought to be enough. She reached down the front of her gown. The crowd opened their wallets and removed cash by the fistful, pulled the rings from their fingers and the jewels from their hair and threw everything at the stage. Marcella raised her hand high, holding the Midnight aloft. It lit the room like a star, bathing everything in a stark white light. The people chanted, Yes, yes, let us see, let us see! She brought the diamond to the front and center of her chest and used its pin to fasten the gown back together. She raised her hands toward the rafters, and the light from the stone shone through her, out of her eyes and her mouth and the tips of her fingers, and the people fell down on the floor and howled with pleasure.
Marcella awoke in the pitch-black of night, sweating and clutching at her chest. The ribbons of her nightgown had become tangled around her neck, and the sharp pin of the diamond dragged across her flesh, leaving a bright red line. She ripped away her nightdress as tears streamed down her face. She gulped water from the delicate glass pitcher she kept beside her bed, trying to make sense of her dream. It had been so beautiful. Did this vision show what higher planes of success were possible if she wore the diamond out in the open?
But it could never be, no matter how wonderful the dream had been. She’d made that mistake once, when she displayed the Midnight at the Porter House ball. Even after disguising it, she’d almost been caught by George Bone. The fear of losing her blue diamond was nearly paralyzing. This was the talisman that gave her the courage and confidence, the very talent, to exist in her new and glorious life. She would not risk sharing it with others. It must stay in the dark, a secret for her alone. Her skin was smarting from the scratch. For the first time in many months, she removed the gem from her person and placed it in its velvet box in a locked drawer in her nightstand.
The next morning, Marcella was shocked when she opened the newspaper. Not because of something it said about her, but because it said nothing at all.
25
Special Collections
Jennie
Jennie walked twenty blocks from Maurice’s office to the main branch of the New York Public Library. The biting winter air was reviving after the suffocating conversation. Had she really just accused Maurice of stealing from his dead friend? And was the dealer correct that Lee was holding out on her? Either way, their conversation had convinced her of one thing: if there was a diamond to be found, she was the one meant to find it. She reached into her pocket to see what time it was and cursed. In her rush to leave, she’d forgotten her phone on Maurice’s desk. It was too late now to double back. They’d surely be locked up for the evening, and anyway she had no desire to see him.
Pushing that problem off until the morning, she concentrated on the new information she’d learned. Was it possible the Midnight was hiding somewhere on Forty-Seventh Street or nearby? Maurice, and maybe Lee, seemed to think so. Pete, too, had clearly been drawn to Little Hope. Her suspicions about his death, set aside just the night before, came roaring back. Lee, Maurice, Peter. All three of them had seen the locket and its LH stamp. What was it the janitor told her? When Peter did the pre-auction inventory, he’d taken out every drawer, pulled out each piece of furniture. If the diamond had been in Little Hope, it clearly wasn’t anymore. Had Peter found it and hidden it somewhere? I think this locket may be the key to something much bigger, he’d said. But, still, in all his careful searching, he’d overlooked the box hidden under the dirty rag, and the ticket stub tucked in the bulletin board. Those tokens from the past were destined for Jennie alone.
At Forty-Second Street, she sped up white marble steps, pushed through revolving doors, and breathed in the soothing old-book scent of the library. The stored wisdom of the place tempered her thoughts. She needed to focus on real, actual facts. Not other people’s hunches. Censuses and maps and newspaper articles and obituaries: the little crumbs that all people left behind—even larger-than-life characters like Marcella Porter and Lana LaValle.
Jennie went to the third floor and found a spot at one of the long tables in the achingly beautiful Rose Reading Room, a real-life relic of the Gilded Age. She tilted her head back, taking in the ceiling, frescoed with the pink clouds of sunset, framed by garlands of gold, and supported by stories-tall windows, now black in the early night of winter. She wondered if Marcella Porter or Lana LaValle had sat in this very room. She thought of the two dark-haired women—one in the sketch, one in the photograph—and considered again if they might be the same person. Enough wondering. Time to get to work. She opened her laptop and logged into the library’s ProQuest database, which allowed her to digitally scan through thousands of newspapers all at once. She typed “Midnight Diamond” into the search bar and took a deep breath. Here we go.
ProQuest returned a dozen newspaper articles. Jennie clicked through, quickly verifying Maurice’s story: in the fall of 1909, the Midnight Diamond, a famous stone from the estate of the late Duke of Eichenwald, was stolen and never seen again. Several pieces expanded on the history of the gem, with a vague story linking the cursed diamond to the duke’s drowning.
If it possesses but one fraction of the evil powers of its larger twin, the infamous Hope Diamond, we can only assume the Duke was doomed from the moment the Midnight came into his possession.
Jennie visited the Smithsonian museum’s website to refresh her memory about the Hope.
Perhaps the most famous object in the Smithsonian’s vast collections, this 45.52-carat blue diamond is believed to have been cut from the French Blue, a large stone stolen during the French Revolution. Originating from the famed Golconda diamond mines of India, the Hope is rumored to carry a curse that brings tragedy and ruin to those who come into close contact with it. Marie Antoinette, Lord Francis Hope, for whose family the stone is named, and American heiress Evalyn Walsh McLean are all supposed victims of this singular stone . . .
A good story, but one Jennie dismissed immediately. While she had no problem believing that her mother’s spirit occasionally came to visit her in the form of a bird, a “curse” was not something she was willing to entertain. People just liked to have something to blame besides their own bad choices.