The thought arrived before she could stop it.
A child of her own, James beside her on a bench like that one, and a future that stretched out warm, certain, and ordinary. He would be good with them. She already knew that, had watched him with Ivy, had seen the tenderness he tried so hard to keep behind his teeth. She could see it if she let herself. She could see all of it.
And then the older, colder thought came up behind the warm one, as it always did.
He had been kind. He had been kind for weeks now, patient, steady, and good, and she had very nearly let herself believe it. But her father had been kind once, too. A father who laughed, lifted her onto his shoulders, and called her his clever girl. And she remembered the winter her mother died, and how that man had simply gone.
Not left. Worse than left.
He had stayed in the house and become a stranger, cold, distant, and closed, and never once in the years that followed had she found the warm father she remembered anywhere within the silent man who wore his face.
Kindness was not a promise. She had learned that at thirteen. A man could be everything gentle in the spring and a locked door by the following winter, and give no warning at all. Lay the weight down and trust the ground to hold, Lady Fenwick said, as though it were a simple thing. But Lady Fenwick had not spent a childhood watching the ground open without warning under a whole family’s feet.
James was kind now. But now was only now. What would he be in ten years, in twenty, when the newness had worn away and she was only the wife across the breakfast table? Would he still stand between her and the world, his hand warm at her back? Or would she wake one ordinary morning to find that the man she had let herself love had quietly become someone she did not know?
She did not know. That was the terrible truth. She had finally handed him her trust, or very nearly, and she still did not know. Standing in the bright park among all those settled and contented mothers, Beatrice found she was more afraid of the answer than she had been of anything in a very long time.
CHAPTER 19
“You look like a man composing poetry in his head and despising himself for every line. Sit down. Drink some of this frankly criminal claret. And tell me what she has done now.”
Duncan’s rooms were exactly as they always were, over-warm and over-furnished, and they smelled of good tobacco. Duncan himself lay draped across a chair in a dressing gown that could have been seen from the moon.
It was the most restful place James knew. There was nowhere on earth he had to pretend less.
They had been friends since they were eleven, thrown together at a school neither of them had cared for, two children with cold houses to go home to, who had recognized the same thing in each other in a dormitory.
Twenty years on, Duncan was still the one person in the world before whom James felt no obligation to be a duke, or a strong man, or anything at all but himself. It was worth more than James had ever told him. He suspected that somehow Duncan knew.
“She has done nothing. That is rather the trouble.”
“It is always the trouble with you. Go on.”
“She is closer than she has ever been. I can feel it.” James turned his glass without drinking. “She stood beside me at the Hartfields’ and took on Pelbury’s whole circle at my side. She laughs with me now. She lets me near her. And still, there is a door somewhere in her that she keeps shut. One last room I cannot get into. I do not know how to reach it without forcing it, and I swore to her I would never force anything. So I wait. And I am running out of patience with my own patience, Duncan, if you want the miserable truth of it.”
“You are the only man I know who could be handed a beautiful, clever, devoted wife by a direct act of God and contrive to be wretched about the fine print.”
But there were no real teeth in Duncan’s words. He did not laugh, and James watched something old surface behind his friend’s eyes.
Duncan was quiet for a moment. Then he set down his glass, which in itself was unusual enough to make James look up.
“I am going to tell you something,” Duncan said, “that I have told no one. And you will not make a great fuss of it afterward, or I shall have to have you killed.”
“Duncan.”
“Her name was Marianne.” He said it lightly, but the lightness was a veneer laid carefully over something else. “This was a lifetime ago, the year my father took me abroad with him. You will remember I was gone the better part of a year and wrote to you perhaps three times, all of it about the food. She was twenty, as I was. She had a laugh that could stop a man’s heart, and she loved me, God knows why, and I loved her past all sense or reason.”
He turned his own glass now, an echo of James without seeming to know it. “And I said nothing. For a year, I said nothing. I was young, and I was proud, and I was quite certain there was all the time in the world, that a thing so plainly meant would keep, that I might play the fool a while longer and speak when I was ready. And while I was so very certain, a duller and braver man than I spoke first. And she married him.”
The fire ticked. Somewhere below in the street, a watchman called the hour.
“I am told she is happy, somewhere in Shropshire, with a great many children and a husband who had the wit to open his mouth when it counted.” Duncan’s smile did not reach his eyes, and for once, he did not try to make it. “I have spent my years in excellent waistcoats and being amusing at parties, and I would trade all of it, every glittering hour, for one afternoon of the courage to have simply told her. That is my sad history, since you have never once asked for it. I lost the best thing I was ever offered because I was too proud to risk being refused, and there is not a day I do not pay for it.”
James did not make a fuss. He now understood a great many things about his friend that he had always taken for simple brightness. He did not offer any of the useless comforts Duncan would only have had to deflect. Instead, he reached over, refilled his friend’s glass, and let the silence say what words would only have spoiled.
After a moment, Duncan gave a small nod, as though some long-standing debt had quietly been settled between them.
“So.” Duncan picked up his glass again, and the mask came down once more, but gently. “Here is my counsel, and it costs you nothing, which is the best kind. Do not be me, James. Do not stand at the shut door, patient, proud, and certain that there is time. Reach for her. Tell her the whole of what you feel and let her do with it what she will. If it frightens her, you will mend it. But do not lose her to your own good manners. It is not worth it. Nothing is worth that. She is worth every risk there is, and so, I promise you, is the having of her.”