“You didn’t do anything wrong. I made a sound because it hurts, not because you hurt me. Those are different things.”
She glances at my arm, then at the kitchen, then back to my arm.
“Touch me again. Please. When you’re ready,” I say, hoping she will try again.
When her fingers finally settle back on my wrist, they’re trembling. She doesn’t look at my face. She watches her own hand like it’s separate from her, like she’s observing someone else’s courage. That’s what this is, I realize. Courage. Not comfort. She’s scared and she’s doing it anyway. I don’t speak. Don’t risk breaking whatever thread she’s holding onto. Her thumb brushes over my skin, then she slowly turns my arm over and her exhale shudders out.
I don’t make another sound. Not because it doesn’t hurt—it does, a deep, grinding soreness that radiates from my shoulder—but because the sound would cost her something. I can see it in the way her jaw is set, the way her lower lip tucks between her teeth. Every second she keeps touching me is a second she’s choosing to stay.
When my arm straightens parallel to the floor, the pain spikes. I bite the inside of my cheek hard enough to taste copper. Her eyes flick to my face, reading something there, and she slows the motion. Adjusts. Eases back a fraction of an inch. The pressure in my shoulder releases just enough.
She’s watching my body the way I watch film. Studying the tells. Learning what works.
We get through three more stretches before she pulls her hands away entirely, wiping them on her jeans. The loss of contact is immediate and cold. She takes a step back, then another, putting distance between us like she’s remembering a rule she forgot.
“What are you making?” I ask, nodding to the kitchen.
She glances at the food she’s pulled out like she doesn’t remember doing it. Her eyes slowly slide to me then she shrugs.
“You know, I can manage in the kitchen. I could take care of you, Elana,” I say softly, my voice getting rougher by the second.
She offers me a small smile and starts chopping green peppers. Considering we have bread, cheese, onions, mushrooms, and meat, I decide to step next to her. I suggest Philly cheesesteaks and she nods after a moment but keeps her eyes away from me.
One step forward is still a step forward, right? It’s progress that makes my whole body feel better than an hour of physical therapy did.
ELANA
Ben stays close and teaches me how to mix things for a Philly cheesesteak. I can’t remember the last time anyone’s worked with me in the kitchen, next to me. Trying to make jokes, encouraging me to taste things, and actually wanting my opinion.
His easy smile, how comfortable he is talking to himself, and the way he ignores his own pain and frustration because he’d rather stay happy and make me feel good sets me off balance. When we finish, Ben watches me take the first bite, as if my approval is worth more than his.
I pause, then meet his eyes.
“Go ahead. I want to make sure you like it. I can always add more sauces, but you can’t take them off, you know?” he asks.
I stretch my lips wide and take the largest bite I can. Ben’s face heats and his eyes darken. I chew, swallow, then lick my bottom lip. It’s delicious, really good, almost enough to distract me from Ben. Ben who suddenly seems really steady, really pleased, and really…
Thank you, I sign in proper ASL.
“Uh…Yeah. You like it?”
I nod and take another bite. Since he’s staring at me with his lips slightly parted, watching me eat, I can’t resist spelling out my teasing. You keep watching me fill my mouth and I’ll think you don’t want to.
“Oh, I definitely want to. So, so much, Elana.” I point to his sandwich and he blinks before shaking his head. “Right. Yeah. That’s…Yeah. I’m starving.”
I have a feeling he’s talking about something else, but I refuse to explore that thought. I’m not getting my hopes up. I’m not willing to forget what drove me from Daisy’s Haven. I can’t force amnesia, even if a part of me wishes I could move past certain things in my life. Ben deserves better. So does Daniel. I can’t give them that.
No matter what I feel, forgetting that will ruin them and I can’t let myself do that. Not after everything they’ve given me.
Twenty-three
ELANA
Ifeel more alone the last few days. Maybe it’s ‘cause I’m starting to feel different. I catch myself watching Ben’s shoulders when he walks by, noticing the way Daniel’s hands look when he signs, and these observations don’t make my throat close up anymore.
They make my chest tight in a different way.
My next breath is sharp at the realization. Ben is out back, working out. Well, more like attempting. I want to help him recover as the guilt weighs heavy on my chest. But how can someone like me truly help him?