Hers totally unblemished, mine scarred.
Innocent and condemned.
The juxtaposition both terrified me and gave me resolve. I would stop at nothing to ensure Penny’s safety. I would do everything in my power to keep her clean and untouched by my work. I would work my ass off to keep her happy and smiling.
“Tell me more about Zane,” she requested.
“Zane? Woman, I’ve had my mouth between your legs and you want me to tell you about another man?”
Penny rolled her eyes. “If I thought you were seriously jealous, I’d tell you that I’m only asking to pass the time. But if you don’t want to talk about him, maybe you can at long last tell me your real name, since as you said, you’ve had your mouth between my legs.”
“My real name is Dutch.”
“Okay, Mister Word Games,” she snorted. “Your other name. The one you were born with.”
Due to her brother and how she came to find him, this was a topic full of landmines, and I needed to tread carefully.
“That man is dead,” I gently told her. “There is no reason to resurrect him. You know me. You know my name. The only one that is important.”
“Will you tell me why that man is dead?”
“I already told you why.”
“Afghanistan,” she whispered.
I nodded. “That was the beginning. I did not lose myself in those mountains like so many did. I found myself. I found the man I wanted to be. After I buried my brother—the last of my blood family—I worked hard to erase every part of my old life. I would never be that man again. I didn’t want to be.”
“My mom is dead,” she whispered like it was a state secret.
“I know.”
I didn’t offer her the lie of my condolences. I hoped the woman was burning in hell for what she did to Penny and Cash.
“Do you think Cash knows?”
“It’s likely he’s looked into her. Or had Kira do it.”
There was no sadness when she went on. “I didn’t tell him. We agreed not to speak of her.”
I had no idea where she was going with this. “Okay.”
“She died when I was in college. Overdose.” She paused and again whispered, but this time it sounded more like a felonious confession. “I didn’t claim her body.”
“Baby—”
“I hated her. I didn’t want anything to do with her. But sometimes I feel this guilt like I should’ve done something.”
The mere fact Penny felt guilt for not giving the woman who abused her a proper funeral was yet another reminder this woman would always be too good for me.
“Penny, you owed her nothing. Not one single thing. Not a funeral. Not your emotions. Nothing. I can understand why you’d feel guilty. You have a soft heart and integrity. But you can’t forget that you’ve been looking out for yourself for a long time and you not claiming her body is just another example of that. You were looking out for you. Your peace, your mental safety. When that was her job. She should’ve been the one protecting you.”
Her eyes were glassy when she nodded. “You’re right.”
I didn’t tell her I knew I was. I also didn’t tell her that it was a good thing the woman was already dead because it saved me a trip to California to hunt her down and rip her heart out of her chest for the hurt she’d caused Penny that had left her with nightmares.
Penny’s voice was still soft when she told me, “I’m jealous that my mom left Cash.”
Her eyes went round and fear saturated her entire body. I let go of her hand to bring mine to the side of her neck and pull her close. “Hey. What’s happening? Why are you—”