Page 83 of What Did They Fear?

Page List

Font Size:

I was still making promises. Promises unfulfilled. Maybe they were as soul-crushing as the unsolved crimes.

SEVENTEEN

ANGEL

Donald was gone about five seconds before Harriet reached for the serving dish nearest to her. “Anyone for more potatoes? There’s plenty.”

Her tone was light, as if Donald had only stepped out to answer the phone. Maybe that was her motherly instinct kicking in. In my family, if Dad had walked out during dinner it would have started an argument that lasted days.

Clay leaned back in his chair, folding his arms. “No more potatoes for me, ’cause I’m officially calling dibs on Mr. D’s dessert.”

“Clayton Beckett.” Harriet attempted a scowl, but the lines around her eyes softened as her smile took over.

“What? Your sticky date pudding is way too good to go to waste.” He winked at her.

Harriet let out a soft, exasperated laugh. “You’ve got more cheek than my three sons put together, Clayton. You’d better eat all that food on your plate first.”

“Yes, Mom.” Clay grinned and stabbed a piece of beef with his fork.

A ripple of easy laughter went around the table, and I had the feeling Clayton was the one who stepped in whenever things got heavy.

And now, the vow I’d made to myself only a moment ago sat like lead in my stomach. I’m going to find Charlotte. The promise felt wrong, almost arrogant, considering everyone at this table had spent two decades searching for her.

But Clayton’s easy warmth softened my worry, and I forced my focus on the wonderful people around me and how comfortable they were with each other.

Harriet stood, and as she dished out her sticky date pudding with caramel sauce, ice cream, and custard, conversation resumed, steering thankfully away from death and bodies.

“Tell them about your afternoon,” Jaxson said, nudging Tory’s shoulder.

Tory shrugged and took a sip of her water. “I rescued a couple of tourists who went way too far on their paddleboards.”

Parker leaned forward. “How far?”

“They got caught in the rip off the outer spit and ended up stuck on the sandbar.”

“Shit. Lucky they got onto that,” Whit said. “They could’ve ended up right out into the sea.”

“Yeah. Except that sandbar goes under at high tide,” Jaxson added. “Tell them what happened.”

Tory fiddled with a silver chain around her neck. “By the time I spotted them, their boards had floated off, and the water was up to the mother’s chest. She had her eight-year-old son on her back. I had to land in the channel and taxi over to haul them in.”

“Were they okay?” Harriet asked.

Tory smiled but shook her head. “Severe sunburn, and sea lice bites all over their skin. They were terrified, but it could’ve ended much worse.”

She said it all so casually while she ate her dessert, as if saving that mother and son wasn’t amazing.

For years, I had convinced myself that digging up and researching cold cases and the human side to these stories on my podcast was saving people, but there was a huge difference between what Tory and I did.

I just talked about the ones who were already lost. Tory actually rescued people.

It made my silent promise to find Charlotte even more potent, but it also made me want to be someone who actually delivered.

Harriet stood and started gathering the dirty dishes.

Whit finished his dessert, wiped his mouth on his napkin, and his hand slid beneath the table, his palm settling on my thigh.

My breath caught in my throat, and my mind raced all over the place as I wondered what his touch meant.


Novels you may like ...