“Really? Was there any connection between them?”
“No. Nothing. Believe me, I’ve deep-dived into Tegan’s life, trying to find something that could connect Tegan to Celeste, but I couldn’t find anything. However, Tegan’s disappearance was similar to Charlotte’s. She was a young girl who vanished after leaving a friend’s party, though she hadn’t fought with her friend. She left the party to walk home alone and was never seen again. Not a trace, just like Charlotte. The case went cold almost immediately.”
He clicked his tongue. “What time did she leave the party?”
“Ten o’clock.”
“Was anyone supposed to pick her up?”
“No. Unlike Charlotte, Tegan was a rebellious teenager. Her mother was raising her on her own.”
“Just like Lola.”
“You’re right. I’ve met with Tegan’s mom, Michelle, many times over the years, and she always blamed herself for not being able to control Tegan, not being stricter. She worked two jobs and was barely home for Tegan.” I shook my head. “It wasn’t Michelle’s fault that some asshole took her.”
He turned his palms up. “Maybe she ran away?”
“Maybe. But if she did, she didn’t take any clothes or jewelry.” I snapped my fingers. “The police found lots of cash in Tegan’s room.”
Whit sat up. “How much?”
“Nearly a thousand dollars. Enough to be suspicious. Tegan didn’t have a part-time job, and her mom had no idea where the money came from. Michelle was working two jobs just to keep the bills paid and to pay rent.”
“Could Tegan have been involved in selling drugs?”
“If she was, it didn’t turn up in the investigation.”
A frown drilled across his forehead. “I hate to suggest this, but what about prostitution? Could she have been involved in that?”
I shrugged. “Again, nothing concrete came up to confirm that. But her disappearance was absolute. She vanished without a trace. Just like Charlotte.”
Whit shook his head slowly. “If there was a connection between Charlotte and Tegan, Parker would’ve flagged it. He’s obsessive about these things.”
“Well, there was a nine-year gap between Charlotte and Tegan,” I pointed out. “And Tegan vanished down in the Bundaberg area. That’s hours away, too far south to fit your sister’s disappearance. Maybe Parker didn’t connect them because of the distance and the timeline.”
Whit stared at me, his mind clearly working through the logistics.
Before he could analyze it further, I tapped the edge of my box. “I need to go through the rest of Charlotte’s files by myself—without you watching every single thing I pull out.”
He scowled, looking offended. “I am not watching you.”
I gave him the side eye. “You’ve been watching me like a hawk all day, Whit.”
“Okay, fine.” He raised his hands in defeat. “But only on one condition. I get to go over your sister’s case. Maybe a fresh set of eyes will see something everyone else missed.”
My chest tightened, a familiar ache blooming behind my ribs. “I wish you could. But everything I had on Celeste was in the Kombi. It’s all gone. My only records are stored on my cloud server. I can pull them up for you, but ...”
Whit wriggled his eyebrows, a sudden, boyish spark breaking through his serious demeanor. “Well, aren’t you lucky that I’m a state forensic pathologist? I have the digital keys to every case file that has ever been logged through the Queensland Police.”
He stood, strode to the kitchen counter, and pulled his sleek silver laptop toward him. “I’ll start with the registered police evidence, and then I’ll check out your cloud files. Give me Celeste’s full name and date of birth.”
I gave him the details, but as his fingers flew across the keyboard, a wave of dread washed over me. Part of me wanted to go to his side, to look over his shoulder and see what he was looking at, but I couldn’t force my legs to move. What I had already been told about how Celeste had died was too much. I didn’t need to see the clinical autopsy reports. I couldn’t bear to see her like that again.
So, we settled into a new rhythm, both of us diving into the separate cold cases, chasing different ghosts. He stayed at the kitchen counter, bathed in the cool blue glow of his laptop screen, while I stayed on the sofa, surrounded by the yellowed papers of his sister’s past.
An hour in, Whit got up and opened another bottle of red wine, pouring each of us a fresh glass. Other than throwing the occasional question at each other, we were mostly silent as we shuffled through our respective ancient files. Every now and then, the silence would stretch so long that I’d glance his way.
Each time, I saw a deep, lingering sadness in his eyes. A heavy grief that I knew probably mirrored my own.