Page 66 of What Did They Fear?

Page List

Font Size:

Holding the coffee mug, I cleared my throat. “Tell me how Charlotte disappeared.” I met his gaze. “But not too much. Just the basics. That way I can learn everything else as I go through the files.”

Whit sipped his coffee, his gaze drifting to the wall. He pointed to a photo of a smiling girl with bright green eyes and long, dark, wavy hair pulled back with a red headband. “Charlotte was our little sister. My brothers and I were seventeen and a half, and Charlotte was sixteen when she went missing. The night she vanished, she’d been to her best friend Lola Ferguson’s seventeenth birthday party. Lola’s house backed onto the nature reserve. Around seven twenty-five, Charlotte and Lola had a fight. The reason for that argument has never been truly established, just silly teenage stuff, according to the police report.”

His jaw clenched, a muscle bulging under his stubble, before he forced it to release. “Charlotte left the party around seven-thirty to walk home. It’s believed she would’ve taken her usual shortcut through the Cedar Grove bushland.”

He stepped closer to the wall and ran his finger along a faded red line on a map.

“She was never seen again. No body, no clothing, no physical evidence of any kind was ever found in those woods or in the streets between our homes. The walk between Lola’s house and ours was about twenty-five minutes. The girls walked through those woods all the time.”

“Even at night? In the dark?” I asked.

His shoulders sagged as if the weight of the memory pressed down on him. “No. Not normally. That night, Parker or Jaxson were supposed to pick her up from the party at ten thirty, but each of them thought the other was doing it.”

He swallowed hard. “I’d gone for a run. Alone. Unfortunately.”

My chest tightened over his absolute sorrow. “But she left the party two and a half hours before the pickup time. Did she let anyone know she was leaving early?”

He shook his head. “She just stormed off. According to Lola, that is.”

“Did Charlotte have a cell phone?”

“No. Mom and Dad couldn’t afford for all four of us to have phones, so none of us did.”

“They were expensive back then,” I said.

“Yes, and not many people had phones in that era, especially not kids, not like these days. Mom and Dad still carry so much guilt over that. They convinced themselves that if Charlotte had possessed a cell phone, she could’ve called us to pick her up. Or if she’d suspected someone was following her, she could’ve called for help.”

“It was a different time back then,” I reminded him, wanting to ease even a fraction of that guilt. “Hardly any teenagers had cell phones, especially in smaller towns where signal was pathetic anyway. You can’t compare back then to today’s standards.”

I studied the map on the wall and the path someone had drawn in red pen between the Callahan house and Lola’s. “It’s not like now, where we track everyone and everything. Half the cold cases I cover would’ve been solved in a day if the victim had been carrying the types of phones we all carry now.”

“Yeah. I guess you’re right.”

“So, when did you realize Charlotte was missing?”

“Lola rang our house after the party was over, wanting to talk to Charlotte. That’s when my brothers realized they had both forgotten to collect her. It’s also when we learned she’d left the party hours earlier. Everything went to shit after that.”

Guilt clouded his eyes. I knew exactly what that looked like. I had lived with that exact same burden for years. The endless what-ifs were heavy bricks to carry, a crushing weight that ruined lives.

I wanted to reach out and tell him that he and his brothers had only been seventeen, that they hadn’t done anything wrong. However, I knew those words would sound hollow. Whit didn’t need a clichéd response. He needed answers.

I sipped my coffee and scanned the walls. “Okay, let’s do this.” I pointed at a close-up photo of a young girl with long blonde hair, bright blue eyes, and rosy cheeks. She wore big blue earrings that matched her eyes. “Who’s that?”

“That’s Lola. She and Charlotte had been friends since primary school. They’d done everything together.”

“So you knew her, too?”

“Sure. She came to our place a lot. Her mom was divorced, and her father wasn’t in the picture. Her mom worked two jobs, so between us and my parents, we were always picking up Charlotte and Lola from netball training, or whatever. Lola had dinner with us many nights while her mom was working at the local cinema.”

“What do you know about her father?”

He frowned, his gaze drifting back to the wall. “He left when Lola was young. Maybe two or three years old. I can’t remember.”

“Do you know his name? What he did for a living? Where he moved to? Was he in touch with Lola at all?”

Whit turned his head, his eyes narrowing slightly. “You think he’s involved?”

I raised a hand. “I don’t think anything yet, but I always start with known contacts, or like this, the obvious connections that are missing.”


Novels you may like ...