Page 64 of What Did They Fear?

Page List

Font Size:

I leaned back, a grim, familiar anger stirring in my chest. “I can relate to that. Bastards.”

“Yes. Bastards.” She let out a raspy breath. “Melanie Delphine. She was the journalist who turned Celeste’s murder into a national spectacle. She didn’t care about Celeste. She cared about ratings, clicks, and the front-page byline. She painted my sister as some wild, reckless girl who invited her own tragedy by being out late. It broke my family. It broke me.”

Her gaze locked onto mine, and her pain shattered me. I knew exactly what she’d gone through.

“I’m sorry you were treated like that, Angel. Nobody should have to fight the people who are supposed to tell the truth.”

She lowered her gaze back to her wrist. The sadness radiating from her was so heavy that every instinct in me wanted to reach across the space between us, pull her into my arms, and hold her until the pain stopped. But I held myself back. I could tell she wouldn’t want that. Angel was like me. She didn’t want pity, and she didn’t want comfort. She wanted answers. She wanted justice.

“That’s why I do this,” she said, her voice steadying as she straightened up. “It’s why I became what I call the anti-journalist. I don’t do sensationalism. I don’t do cheap suspense. I do this soul-crushing work, detailing the creeps and assholes who ruin lives, to help the families and friends left behind because I could never do it for my sister. I was too young, too broken.”

She turned her wrist toward me, showing me the little firefly once more.

“The firefly is for Celeste. Bringing a little light into the darkness. For some of these families, my podcast is the only thing that lets them finally breathe, and sometimes, giving them the truth actually lets them move on.”

And just like that, one piece of the puzzle that was Angel fell into place. I finally understood what she had meant when she had said she knew my kind of pain.

Two sisters’ lives ruined. Two cases gone cold.

The only difference was that Celeste had been found, though her murder was brutal and shocking. My sister’s body had never been recovered. Charlotte was just a ghost, leaving us with no closure, no grave, trapped in a permanent, agonizing loop of what-ifs.

I didn’t know which was worse.

Angel cracked a tight, fragile smile. “So, yeah. I’m the anti-journalist. It’s a thrilling career choice—highly recommend it if you hate sleep and enjoy death threats.”

The joke was dry as bone, but it let a little air back into the room.

I leaned against the counter. “You’re speaking to a man who has despised journalists on principle for twenty years. And yet, I think I’ve just met someone who despises them more than I do.”

“Oh, I definitely win that contest.” A spark flared in her eyes. “Did your local paper ever write an entire editorial debating whether your sister’s choice of clothing made her an easy target?”

“Fuck. No,” I replied, deadpan. “But they did run a front-page photo of my brothers and me on our front lawn with the headline: The Silent Brothers: What Are They Hiding? Apparently, we weren’t crying enough for the cameras.”

“Bastards.” Her tone carried a hint of dark, mock appreciation. “But did they interview your high school teacher to ask if you had ‘dark tendencies’ because you failed math?”

“I didn’t fail math,” I said.

A sudden, genuine laugh escaped her lips. It was a bright, cheerful sound that seemed entirely out of place after everything we’d just discussed.

I liked her laugh. I found myself hoping that she would laugh more often.

Her honesty had loosened a knot woven tight inside me. We had a shared enemy, and that bitter common ground had done what sympathy never could. Neither of us wanted sympathy anyway. We wanted answers.

I took a breath and looked down at my hands on the counter.

“Charlotte vanished twenty years ago,” I said. The admission still felt heavy, but it didn’t cut the way it usually did. “She was sixteen. She went to a party and never came home. Bob Ackerman was one of the responding officers who worked her case back then.”

Angel gasped. “Jesus. Ackerman? What the hell? I didn’t know that.”

“Yeah. He was a bastard even back then.” I forced myself to meet her eyes. “Because the police couldn’t find her, and because my brothers, Parker and Jaxson, were supposed to pick her up that night and didn’t ... the suspicion landed on us. Mostly on me, because I couldn’t substantiate exactly where I was around the time Charlotte went missing. People looked at me like I’d done something to my own sister. The rumor has followed me forever. It’s the reason I didn’t pass the police psych exam.” I shrugged. “It’s the reason I became a forensic pathologist. I deal with the absolute truth. Bodies don’t lie. Evidence doesn’t make up bullshit.”

“Huh.” She studied me, her gaze tracing the lines of my face. “I never understood why anyone would want that job. I get it now. I bet you’re damn good at it.”

“I am.”

I had more I could tell her. So much more. But I stopped there. Twenty years of accumulated rage, grief, and frustration backed up behind my teeth. But I didn’t need to say anymore.

She didn’t push or offer hollow platitudes, and she didn’t look at me with that suffocating pity I had spent half my life avoiding.


Novels you may like ...