Page 109 of What Did They Fear?

Page List

Font Size:

“Is it weird that she’s not in any other photo?” Whit asked.

I shrugged. “Not really. They’re a bunch of random pictures from a party. If there’d been a group shot with everyone in it and she still wasn’t there, then I’d be suspicious.”

Whit groaned. “The necklace could mean nothing. It could be a cheap pendant from Kmart, for all we know.”

“I don’t think it was cheap. When I saw it in Tegan’s room, I remember thinking it looked expensive compared to all her other jewelry.”

“Do you think Tegan’s mom would still have it?” Whit asked.

“I don’t know, but I need to call her anyway. I haven’t spoken to her since we found Tegan’s body.” I let out a shaky breath. “I need to see how she is.”

“Ahhh, shit,” I moaned.

“What?” Whit asked.

“Her number was in my phone.”

“I’ll get it for you. It’ll be in the autopsy report.” Whit leaned over and rested his hand briefly on my leg. “Give me a sec.” He pushed back from the table and strode away.

I went to the bathroom. Once inside and the door shut, I sat on the toilet lid and pressed my hands against my thighs.

Hope and worry tangled inside me so tightly I could hardly separate one from the other.

What if I was wrong?

What if I was right?

Both questions felt equally loaded.

After a minute, I stood, splashed water on my face at the sink, then went back to the living area.

Whit held out his phone. “Michelle’s number is ready to dial.”

“Thank you.”

I slipped out the back door and down the weathered wooden steps to the dock. The air outside was thicker, warmer, and rich with the dark smell of tidal water and mangroves. By the time I reached the end of the narrow jetty, the soft slap of the river against the pilings below had become its own little heartbeat. I winced when the scars on my legs twinged as I sat down and dangled my legs over the edge. I stared at the tea-brown water for a moment before I pressed call.

“Hello?” Michelle answered the way she always did, as if she were faintly surprised someone had actually called.

“Hi, Michelle. It’s Angel.”

“Oh, love.” She paused, and in that silence, I could hear all the things neither of us knew how to say first.

“I’m so sorry.” I closed my eyes. There was never a way to say sorry that came close to what I actually meant.

“My beautiful girl,” she said at last, so softly it nearly undid me. “She was dead all this time.”

The ache in her voice was enough on its own. It didn’t need embellishment. That was one thing I’d learned over the years doing this work: grief was rarely most devastating when it was loud. More often, it lived in the words left unsaid.

“I’m sorry it took so long,” I said finally.

“It wasn’t your fault,” she answered, firmer than I expected. “You were the only one who kept trying. You kept her name alive.”

I swallowed against the tightness in my throat and looked out over the water, where the last of the light lay in broken strips across the channel.

“They found her,” Michelle said again as if she were still trying to make the words real. “At least my Tegan isn’t lost anymore.”

At least she wasn’t lost anymore.


Novels you may like ...