Cas had finally agreed to therapy on the condition that I would get some too. Now, after months of seeing someone and talking through our fears and feelings, we were both doing better. Neither of us was completely past what had happened, but I didn’t expect we would ever really be, and that was okay.
“Hmmm,” Cas hummed from the driver’s seat beside me, “I think I agree, but you still have to keep it on.” I crossed my arms and fake pouted in my seat, hiding a smile when that chuckle I’d been hoping for sounded.
Cas reached over and tugged my arm from where it was locked with my other. Then, he took my hand and lifted it. The feeling of his lips pressing a kiss to my skin sent shivers through me. The smallest things this man did could turn me on. Hell, I walked in and found him drying dishes one night, having sent Lief home early for a bit of a break. I jumped his bones. Right there in the kitchen. I couldn’t help it. Turns out, a domesticated male is an aphrodisiac I never knew existed.
I shook off the memory and asked, “Do I get even a tiny hint?”
“It’s something I think you’ll love.” Well, that didn’t help. I already knew that. Still, I couldn’t help teasing him a bit.
“Something I’ll love…” I mused while tapping my finger to my chin. Smiling brightly, I over-enthusiastically guessed, “You hired Jensen Ackles as permanent living art in the manor halls?”
There went that growl I loved so much. I couldn’t help teasing him about his possessive streak, secretly I loved it. I loved how it made me feel loved, cherished, protected. Because I was those things. Even all these months later, Cas had a hard time letting me out of his sight. After so many years of being just an accessory, I relished being the center of someone’s world. If it came with having ‘The Monster of Midland’ shadowing me...well, all the better, in my opinion.
“Bunny…” Oh! That warning tone sent shivers up my spine and heat to my core. That low tone was the same one he’d use right before lighting my ass up like a Christmas tree. My body was now trained to respond to it in delicious ways.
“Cas…” I tried to sound annoyed but even I could hear the arousal dripping from that one word. There was no doubt he’d heard it too.
We drove for a few minutes in comfortable silence. I tried to guess where we were going from the turns we took. It might have worked if I had done that from the moment he picked me up at the station. But I’d been too preoccupied. It was still my first week back at work, which had been playing with my mind a bit.
The new sheriff’s office looked very different from the old one, the city council having decided to upgrade the building since it had to be rebuilt anyway. Still, going back in there brought back memories. Cas had suggested that I find another job. I’d actually considered it, but I liked Collin, the new sheriff, and I didn’t want to let memories hold me back. So, I’d stuck it out. I wasn’t completely comfortable yet, but it was getting better each day.
“How much further?” I asked.
“Funny you should ask,” he replied as he slowed and took another turn. “We’re here. And before you ask, no. You cannot remove the blindfold yet.”
The engine shut off, I heard the click of his door opening, the thump of it closing, then my door opened. Cas reached in and undid my seatbelt, then helped me out of the car and directed me where to step.
“Step up here. Up again.” There was the jangle of keys, the displacement of air around me, “Be careful not to bump into the frame there.” He led me further into the building before instructing me to stay there. I heard the rustling of clothes and wondered if I was about to get some sexy time after all when he took my hand and finally told me I could take off the blindfold.
It took a minute for my eyes to adjust to the change of light. When they did, my vision was immediately blurred by tears. I was standing in my great aunt’s house, but it had been transformed. Completely remodeled. Not just any remodel, either. As I looked around, memories flooded me with the force of a tidal wave.
“A yellow kitchen!” I yelled at Cas.
“Why can’t the kitchen be another color?”
“Because, yellow is happy and kitchens are happy and a kitchen should be yellow.” It made perfect sense to my ten-year-old self.
“What should this area of our house be?” Cas asked, standing another patch of grass from where we’d designated the kitchen would be.
“That’s the living room and right where you’re standing is the fireplace so you might want to move before the hot stones burn you.”
“I’m safe. The stones on the outside of a fireplace don’t get hot. Just the ones inside, where the fire is.”
“Do you know everything?” I huffed as he laughed.
“Sabrina Saint,” Cas’ words pulled me from the memories and back to the present where I found him kneeling before me, holding a simple and beautiful ring, “From the moment I found you trapped in a fence, I knew you’d changed my life. Now, I can’t imagine my life without you in it. I love you. Will you marry me?”
I took another look around the building, the exact replica of every description we ever gave of our cute little cottage. He had taken the time and put in the effort to create this special place, because the only thing he has ever wanted is for me to be safe, happy, and loved. There was only one answer to give.
“Yes!”
Epilogue
Caspar
Eleven and a half months later
“What the heck is going on here?”