Hearing his zipper, she hastily glanced over her shoulder. Before she could object, she felt him nudging at her opening, and every thought of stopping him flew out of her mind.
She expected him to thrust inside her, but after several seconds, she dazedly realized he couldn’t. Her body should have easily accepted him, yet it resisted every attempt.
What the hell? she nearly screamed in sexual frustration. Then she realized what the problem was.
It wasn’t her.
It was Wizard.
“Uh … I don’t think this is going to work.” She tried to move away, but Wizard held her steady.
“Give it a minute. You’ll adjust.” He groaned, lowering his head to her shoulder.
“I’ll never adjust to that,” she moaned.
“You will.” He pressed his mouth to the side of her neck.
Her hips arched back when he sucked the delicate skin into his mouth. Desperately trying to give it another go, she tried to relax. If she didn’t come soon, she felt as if her body would ignite.
She needed him inside her, but her body couldn’t accommodate his size. It wasn’t because she didn’t want him—she was pulsing with need. He should have been able to slide in with ease.
Pressing her forehead to the wall, she gripped the edge of the table and whimpered.
“Relax,” he whispered against her neck.
“That’s easy for you to say,” she muttered.
“This isn’t easy for me, either.”
When Wizard tried again, her body shook.
“You should come with a warning,” she hissed. “It’s like trying to fit a size-thirteen foot into a size-five shoe.”
“It’ll fit,” he promised seductively. “Give me a second. Let me…” His hand slid around her hip to find her clit. “Sometimes this happens. I just need to get you wetter.”
Her mind abruptly cleared. This certainly isn’t his first rodeo, she thought sarcastically. She bet Wizard had been with more women than he could count.
“This isn’t working. Let’s stop,” she told him coolly, finally back in control of her emotions and body.
“Fuck.” Wizard immediately pulled away.
Instead of banging her head against the wall for being such a damn fool, Natalia forced herself to face the consequences. She turned around and saw Wizard wincing as he shoved his hard cock back into his jeans.
“Sorry,” she muttered, picking up her panties and jeans to hold in front of her bare body.
“We could—”
Natalia shook her head instantly. “I don’t think so. We got carried away. This is our bodies telling us we don’t fit together. Which, honestly, we already knew—we’re not compatible.”
Wizard’s expression turned angry. “That’s bullshit!”
She winced at the volume of his voice. “Name one thing we have in common.”
“I’ve wanted you from the first moment I saw you,” he revealed. “You had to feel the same, or you wouldn’t have responded to me so fast.”
“I can’t say the same,” she lied, keeping her tone even. “I underestimated just how good you are at reeling a woman into bed. You’re good.”.
“Obviously, not good enough,” he growled, finally able to zip up his jeans.