Page 104 of Where Sinners Repent

“Every scar, every burn on his body is my fault.” Kaleb’s voice sounds like it’s cleaving through his body; the man completely unravelling in front of me. “They were to punish me! They should have been on me!”

Tears slide down my cheeks before I even realise that I’m crying. Grief for these boys hits me so strong, my knees buckle.

“I’m sorry, brother,” Kaleb sobs, his abs rippling with every movement. “I’m so fucking sorry.”

Kai is a silent force behind me; his intensity radiating off him like heat against my back. Kaleb’s breathing turns ragged, each inhale dragging through his heaving chest. His jaw clenches so hard that the muscles jump, but even his iron grip can’t stop the trembling running through his sweat slicked body.

A drop beads down his face. His eyes clench shut for a second before snapping open again, desperate to reclaim control.

He looks like a fallen angel. And now I want to put him back together again.

“Eyes on me,” I murmur, falling to my knees.

For some reason, he listens, his hazy gaze landing on mine. Reaching around, I turn the vibrations off, but leave the toy in.

“Thank you for sharing that,” I rasp, emotion clogging my throat. “You did so well for me, Kaleb. I’m so proud.”

His lip trembles, and the sight cleaves through my heart.

“You are going to give me one more, babe,” I murmur, licking a stripe down his swollen cock. “Can you do that for me?”

His face twists in a wince, but after a long second, he nods. I suck him into my mouth. This time, instead of fast and rough, I take my time. My tear-filled eyes stay on his.

My tongue laps at his swollen cock, and I gently hollow my cheeks. It doesn’t take long until his hips are chasing more, thrusting down my throat.

A pained groan slips past his lips as he sprays cum onto my tongue.

Chapter 26

Kaleb

Everything. Fucking. Hurts.

My body. My cock. My heart.

The toy is tugged from my ass and my entire body shudders, slumping against the restraints.

This girl. This fucking girl.

If I’m moving past the fact that she tied me up and fucking ruined me, which I’m not, then I’d be impressed.

Because even though my body feels like soft cement, a crushing weight has been removed from my shoulders. It doesn’t take away what happened. But apologising to my brother is something I’ve been too cowardly to do.

Her lips shine with my arousal, dark makeup dripping down her cheek. Black hair cascades down her back, and her eyes shine even in this dungeon.

“Black Cat,” I whisper, voice coming out broken.

She places her finger against my lips, looking up at me in a way she hasn’t done before. Something soft shines in her eyes. It’s a look I don’t deserve.

“Shhh, Kaleb,” she soothes, running a soft hand down my sweaty body, slowly bringing me back. “I’ve got you.”

I didn’t realise that I’m crying. But a warm tear trickles down my cheek.

Kai steps towards me, his eyes never moving from mine. Together they unchain my ankles, and my knees buckle, the restraints on my wrists are the only thing holding me up. Until Kai steps closer, propping my body up while he works on the wrist straps one at a time.

I all but fall on top of him when I’m released, sagging against his weight. For most brothers, the fact that I’m naked and spent, draped over my brother would be weird. We aren’t most brothers.

A broken sound escapes me, a shuddering breath heaving out of me.