“It doesn’t matter.” Tyler shakes his head. “I shouldn’t have taken it out on you. I’m sorry.”
The apology hangs between us, sincere and unexpected. I run my fingers through his hair, still messy from sleep and our…activities. “I wasn’t exactly innocent either. I provoked you sometimes.”
A smile tugs at the corner of his mouth. “Yeah, you did. It worked, too.” His eyes darken. “Also, because even when I hated you, I still felt…protective. Maybe even a little possessive.”
A flush spreads across his cheekbones as he admits this, and I’m struck by how strangely endearing it is to see Tyler Murphy—confident, cocky Tyler—blush. My heart thuds in my chest.
“I don’t mind,” I admit, my voice dropping lower. “I like that you’re possessive.”
“Good,” he growls and nips at the sensitive skin below my ear. “Because I’ve been watching both girls and guys check you out for years, and it drives me fucking crazy.”
I gasp as he sucks hard enough to leave a mark. “You never said anything.”
“Because I wasn’t supposed to care.” His hand slides down my chest, fingers splaying across my stomach before moving lower. “I wasn’t supposed to want my stepbrother.”
When his hand wraps around me, I arch into his touch, all coherent thought fleeing. “Tyler—”
“But I want you,” he continues, his strokes slow and deliberate. “Have for a long time. Been driving myself crazy, trying not to think about you like this.”
I reach for him, finding him hard. His breath hitches as I match his rhythm. “Like what?”
He kisses me, deep and demanding. “Like mine,” he murmurs against my lips.
We move together, hands working in tandem, mouths crashing in hungry kisses. It’s less frantic than last night, but no less intense—the morning light making everything more real, more vulnerable. When we finally come, moments apart, Tyler holds me close through the aftershocks, whispering my name.
Later, as we lie catching our breath, I trace the defined muscles of his chest and admit, “I don’t want to leave this place.”
Tyler’s fingers thread through my hair. “Why not?”
“I’m afraid,” I confess, the words difficult to push past the lump in my throat. “Afraid this is some kind of dream ortemporary insanity. That once we go back home, we’ll revert to how things were.”
Tyler shifts, tilting my chin up to meet his gaze. His eyes are serious, intense. “I won’t be able to go back, Liam. Not after I’ve finally had you.” His thumb brushes across my lower lip. “Could you? Go back to how things were between us?”
“God, no.” The very thought makes my chest ache. “I much prefer this version of you.”
He smiles, but it fades. “Shit. Our parents are going to freak out.”
“Mom will be horrified,” I agree, picturing her shocked expression.
“We should tell them together,” Tyler says suddenly, his arm tightening around me.
I nod, comforted by the thought of facing them with Tyler by my side. “The look on your dad’s face is going to be priceless.”
Tyler laughs, the sound vibrating through his chest against my ear. “Their vow renewal in August will be awkward.”
“It’ll bespectacularlyawkward.” I grin despite myself as I imagine the sideways glances, the whispered conversations that will start when we enter a room.
Tyler shifts beneath me, pulling me closer until there’s no space left between us, only warmth and the steady thump of his heart under my cheek. “Whatever happens,” he says, his voice soft but firm, “I’m not letting you go.”
It hits me then—this isn’t just about lust or some forbidden thrill. It’s about all the years we spent circling each other with bared teeth, not realizing we were guarding the same ache. Itighten my arm around him and nod against his chest, too full of emotion to speak.
Outside the cabin, the birds have gone quiet, and the only sound is the wind in the trees. Inside, everything feels suspended, like we’ve stepped into a different version of our lives—one where we’re allowed to want this, to want each other.
Tyler brushes a kiss into my hair. “When we get home, we’ll figure it out,” he promises. “We’ll take it one day at a time.”
I lift my head to meet his gaze. “Okay,” I whisper. And I mean it. I’m not afraid of what comes next.
Tyler’s hand finds mine beneath the sheets, fingers lacing through mine with a certainty that leaves no room for doubt. We stay like that for a while, not speaking, not moving, just holding on.
And for the first time, we’re not pretending anymore.
The End